1
00:00:00,191 --> 00:00:05,513
SPEAKER_00: Today, enough people will die in car crashes to fill a 737.

2
00:00:06,433 --> 00:00:08,853
SPEAKER_00: And that happened yesterday, and that'll happen tomorrow.

3
00:00:09,274 --> 00:00:15,035
SPEAKER_01: Today's guest is Pete Buttigieg, former presidential candidate and secretary of transportation.

4
00:00:15,215 --> 00:00:25,478
SPEAKER_01: Why do you think folks in the Democratic Party, higher-ups, have been so skeptical or nervous about coming into these new formats, Jubilee, podcasts,

5
00:00:25,638 --> 00:00:30,099
SPEAKER_00: Generally, in my party, for some reason, there's a real allergy to taking risk.

6
00:00:30,399 --> 00:00:39,182
SPEAKER_01: Of course, we talked about politics, issues like airline safety, autonomous vehicles, and various things he was responsible for a few years ago.

7
00:00:39,662 --> 00:00:44,183
SPEAKER_01: But we also opened things up and spoke about his personal relationship with healthcare.

8
00:00:44,643 --> 00:00:50,224
SPEAKER_01: Specifically, the life and death case of RSV his son battled with as a newborn.

9
00:00:50,324 --> 00:00:52,525
SPEAKER_00: The image I can't get out of my mind is how tiny he was.

10
00:00:55,475 --> 00:00:59,098
SPEAKER_00: all this gear coming out of his throat.

11
00:00:59,918 --> 00:01:02,961
SPEAKER_00: There's only one question we really care about, of course, which is like, is he getting better?

12
00:01:03,441 --> 00:01:04,682
SPEAKER_00: How will we know when he's getting better?

13
00:01:05,022 --> 00:01:09,486
SPEAKER_00: And basically what they told us was, you'll know he's getting better when he stops getting worse.

14
00:01:10,507 --> 00:01:13,430
SPEAKER_01: Please help me in welcoming Pete Buttigieg to the Checkup Podcast.

15
00:01:13,810 --> 00:01:16,913
SPEAKER_01: Mayor Pete, Secretary Pete, what's... Let's just go with Pete.

16
00:01:17,153 --> 00:01:17,373
SPEAKER_01: Pete.

17
00:01:17,513 --> 00:01:17,914
SPEAKER_01: Oh, Pete.

18
00:01:17,954 --> 00:01:18,574
SPEAKER_01: Okay, I like it.

19
00:01:19,375 --> 00:01:26,261
SPEAKER_01: I'm excited for you to be here because you're a person that is in politics but out of politics.

20
00:01:26,781 --> 00:01:30,245
SPEAKER_01: You're a person that thrives in a debate format.

21
00:01:30,905 --> 00:01:41,332
SPEAKER_01: In fact, one of the most exciting things that I saw you do that I think not enough politicians do is step inside the social media world known as Jubilee surrounded.

22
00:01:42,253 --> 00:01:47,556
SPEAKER_01: You sat surrounded by undecided voters and you took on tough questions.

23
00:01:47,977 --> 00:01:51,379
SPEAKER_01: You were very empathetic in your approach, but at the same time, no nonsense.

24
00:01:52,099 --> 00:01:55,842
SPEAKER_01: And I did something quite similar to that with individuals who are anti-vaccine.

25
00:01:55,862 --> 00:02:00,425
SPEAKER_01: And then a second time for those who support the Maha movement or Secretary Kennedy.

26
00:02:01,875 --> 00:02:05,143
SPEAKER_01: What are your thoughts or reflections on doing that?

27
00:02:05,324 --> 00:02:06,727
SPEAKER_01: And what did you think going into that?

28
00:02:06,747 --> 00:02:09,534
SPEAKER_01: Because most politicians shy away from that format.

29
00:02:09,850 --> 00:02:13,771
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean, to me, the beating heart of politics is persuasion.

30
00:02:14,111 --> 00:02:22,694
SPEAKER_00: It's the idea that you care about something, you have values, you have ideas, you have policies that you believe in, and you want to convince people that that's the right way to go.

31
00:02:23,074 --> 00:02:27,316
SPEAKER_00: So by definition, you need to be talking to people who don't already believe that.

32
00:02:28,096 --> 00:02:33,038
SPEAKER_00: And I'm a little struck by how little of that goes on right now.

33
00:02:33,058 --> 00:02:34,258
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, why is that?

34
00:02:34,678 --> 00:02:38,062
SPEAKER_00: Well, look, I think a lot of it is the kind of the work of the algorithm, right?

35
00:02:38,102 --> 00:02:42,727
SPEAKER_00: Social media tends, when it comes to politics, it tends to feed us one of a couple of things.

36
00:02:42,867 --> 00:02:51,135
SPEAKER_00: One is, here's this person I already agree with doing something I already agree with, or it's, you know, here's this person I already don't like doing something that reminds me why I don't like them, right?

37
00:02:51,176 --> 00:02:51,416
SPEAKER_00: Right, yeah.

38
00:02:51,896 --> 00:03:00,419
SPEAKER_00: And part of what I appreciate about the Jubilee the Surrounded format is kind of by its nature, it's people with different viewpoints encountering each other.

39
00:03:00,599 --> 00:03:12,724
SPEAKER_00: And it's interesting, it can be riveting, but it's also just important because it's that actual work of trying to convince somebody of something, or at the very least, hold your own for what you believe, talking to somebody who believes the opposite.

40
00:03:13,024 --> 00:03:17,326
SPEAKER_01: Yeah, but you're also going to a platform where they have control over the edit,

41
00:03:18,626 --> 00:03:23,474
SPEAKER_01: It's basically an as live format with people asking all sorts of questions.

42
00:03:24,075 --> 00:03:25,136
SPEAKER_01: Any fear going into that?

43
00:03:25,156 --> 00:03:31,566
SPEAKER_01: Because I know for myself, I was very worried that I felt like I was representing the entire medical community in those moments.

44
00:03:32,006 --> 00:03:33,028
SPEAKER_01: Did you feel any of that?

45
00:03:33,641 --> 00:03:38,384
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean, I think anytime you go into an interview that's unfamiliar, there's a level of trust there.

46
00:03:38,404 --> 00:03:40,065
SPEAKER_00: I mean, I've never interviewed with you before, right?

47
00:03:40,145 --> 00:03:52,052
SPEAKER_00: But to me, again, part of how you, especially if you're a political figure, but any kind of public figure, hopefully you relish taking what you have to say to different places and different formats.

48
00:03:52,872 --> 00:03:58,597
SPEAKER_00: And I'll be honest, I didn't know about that format until it was pitched for me to do it.

49
00:03:59,057 --> 00:04:03,041
SPEAKER_00: But then in order to get ready, I watched some of the others who had done it, mainly people I disagreed with.

50
00:04:03,081 --> 00:04:06,143
SPEAKER_00: I watched Charlie Kirk on Surrounded and Ben Shapiro.

51
00:04:06,183 --> 00:04:10,367
SPEAKER_00: And in addition to thinking about what I would say in that format, it just helped me think about what I believe.

52
00:04:10,988 --> 00:04:20,819
SPEAKER_00: And I wish we had more forums and formats where you see the two sides kind of encountering each other or however many sides there are to an issue.

53
00:04:20,919 --> 00:04:22,160
SPEAKER_00: And it helps you figure out what you think.

54
00:04:22,300 --> 00:04:24,122
SPEAKER_00: Sometimes the other side persuades you.

55
00:04:24,623 --> 00:04:29,308
SPEAKER_00: Just as often, hearing the other side actually makes you understand what you believe better than before.

56
00:04:29,368 --> 00:04:30,830
SPEAKER_00: But the point is you think about it.

57
00:04:31,830 --> 00:04:40,253
SPEAKER_00: And I think that's just so core to what communications media public life should be about, but there's less and less of it right now.

58
00:04:40,473 --> 00:04:40,713
SPEAKER_00: Yeah.

59
00:04:41,053 --> 00:04:46,635
SPEAKER_01: Did you get negativity or any negative criticism for just involving yourself with that platform?

60
00:04:47,125 --> 00:04:48,285
SPEAKER_00: I think it was a little bit of skepticism.

61
00:04:48,385 --> 00:04:54,727
SPEAKER_00: Definitely some folks said, look, like you're, in fact, at the time, I was appearing as a campaign surrogate, like as a volunteer.

62
00:04:55,887 --> 00:04:59,848
SPEAKER_00: But I also had the day job of being the secretary of transportation.

63
00:04:59,888 --> 00:05:04,269
SPEAKER_00: So it was this question of should a cabinet official be doing this, even in a private capacity?

64
00:05:05,269 --> 00:05:16,992
SPEAKER_00: But I think if you think anything's beneath you, especially when you're talking about ways of reaching millions of people in an electoral season, you're kind of missing what's going on in our current moment of politics.

65
00:05:17,172 --> 00:05:23,999
SPEAKER_00: where, look, not everybody's looking to established credentialed institutional media to get their news.

66
00:05:24,640 --> 00:05:32,447
SPEAKER_00: And I say that as somebody who actually believes that their role is very important because they have to follow journalistic standards that not everybody does.

67
00:05:33,348 --> 00:05:36,851
SPEAKER_00: But that's clearly just not where so many people look to first.

68
00:05:37,912 --> 00:05:46,359
SPEAKER_00: And it's less important that I agree with a presenter or an interviewer than it is that there's an audience that trusts them.

69
00:05:46,839 --> 00:05:51,163
SPEAKER_00: And if there's an audience that trusts them, I should trust that audience to care what I have to say.

70
00:05:51,863 --> 00:06:06,270
SPEAKER_01: Yeah, that's such a good point because a lot of times I'll get criticism for doing something like the Jubilee episode where some of the statements they'll say, why are you platforming, essentially platforming those who have anti-vaccine beliefs?

71
00:06:06,310 --> 00:06:07,730
SPEAKER_01: You're giving them more credibility.

72
00:06:08,091 --> 00:06:10,912
SPEAKER_01: Science like this that's well-established shouldn't be debated.

73
00:06:12,365 --> 00:06:15,706
SPEAKER_01: And they say the same when I would make appearances on Fox News.

74
00:06:16,546 --> 00:06:17,967
SPEAKER_01: They would say, why are you going on there?

75
00:06:18,007 --> 00:06:20,787
SPEAKER_01: They're spreading misinformation and those are their beliefs.

76
00:06:21,448 --> 00:06:26,129
SPEAKER_01: But I would say, if I'm not gonna go on there, then who is gonna go on there?

77
00:06:26,189 --> 00:06:27,689
SPEAKER_01: And the problem will just persist.

78
00:06:28,569 --> 00:06:30,230
SPEAKER_01: And perhaps there's something to be learned.

79
00:06:30,750 --> 00:06:43,741
SPEAKER_01: Like I learned a lot from the participants who had vaccine hesitancy or even anti-vaccine notions, maybe not so much from a scientific perspective, but from a human standpoint of what their concerns were, how did they end up there?

80
00:06:44,322 --> 00:06:53,469
SPEAKER_01: Because to me, the harsh reality is we, if guided a little bit differently in our lives, had we been in a different situation, could have ended up in that seat.

81
00:06:54,310 --> 00:06:57,432
SPEAKER_01: And people neglect that for some reason, especially in politics.

82
00:06:57,553 --> 00:06:57,753
SPEAKER_00: Yes.

83
00:06:57,833 --> 00:07:06,999
SPEAKER_00: And that's one of the core realities of politics is, of course, if I had a different life experience and was raised with different values and had different surroundings, I might have different political values.

84
00:07:07,140 --> 00:07:14,445
SPEAKER_00: And that's true for all of us have to admit that, you know, none of us got our, you know, many of us may have broken away from how we were raised politically or think

85
00:07:15,125 --> 00:07:17,087
SPEAKER_00: I'm not negating that people think for themselves.

86
00:07:17,807 --> 00:07:26,312
SPEAKER_00: I'm just saying that none of our political values are sort of linked to unambiguous cosmic truth that came down on tablets from the heavens.

87
00:07:26,352 --> 00:07:28,634
SPEAKER_01: It's not clearly a genetic, it's nature and nurture.

88
00:07:28,654 --> 00:07:31,236
SPEAKER_00: We figured out what we believe and other people have too.

89
00:07:31,436 --> 00:07:33,497
SPEAKER_00: And we're all right about something and wrong about something.

90
00:07:33,697 --> 00:07:40,102
SPEAKER_00: And I say that as somebody who's passionately full of conviction about the things that I believe in, that I care about, which is why I go out and defend them.

91
00:07:40,482 --> 00:07:43,605
SPEAKER_00: But yeah, one thing you and I have in common, I think, is going on Fox News.

92
00:07:43,685 --> 00:07:44,946
SPEAKER_00: And my view is like yours.

93
00:07:45,366 --> 00:07:49,729
SPEAKER_00: How can I blame somebody for not agreeing with me if they've literally never even heard what I have to say?

94
00:07:49,749 --> 00:07:50,670
SPEAKER_00: Of course they don't share my opinion.

95
00:07:50,730 --> 00:07:56,174
SPEAKER_01: Or have heard it through a medium of someone else interpreting what you're saying, as opposed to exactly what you would want to say.

96
00:07:56,194 --> 00:07:56,535
SPEAKER_01: Exactly.

97
00:07:57,676 --> 00:07:59,958
SPEAKER_01: I saw you the other day on CNBC, I believe it was.

98
00:07:59,978 --> 00:08:04,102
SPEAKER_01: You had a pretty heated discussion and you seemed very passionate.

99
00:08:05,724 --> 00:08:07,025
SPEAKER_01: Maybe some would say riled up.

100
00:08:07,345 --> 00:08:08,947
SPEAKER_01: Do you feel emotional in those moments?

101
00:08:08,967 --> 00:08:09,868
SPEAKER_01: How do you control yourself?

102
00:08:09,888 --> 00:08:10,668
SPEAKER_01: What's your strategy?

103
00:08:13,735 --> 00:08:37,472
SPEAKER_00: i'm very passionate about what i believe in i don't think i'm like i don't gesticulate i'm not like as like you know uh um fiery or emotional you know kind of in how i how i express that usually uh but like i get fired up in the moment sometimes especially when somebody's saying something i think is not true or if i care about persuading them i mean i think there's again if if i didn't think it was worth

104
00:08:39,135 --> 00:08:43,218
SPEAKER_00: challenging somebody if I didn't respect them enough to challenge them, there'd be no energy there, right?

105
00:08:43,638 --> 00:08:47,161
SPEAKER_00: I actually like going in there and sparring with people I disagree with.

106
00:08:47,441 --> 00:08:50,504
SPEAKER_00: I care about what they think, or at least I care about challenging what they have to say.

107
00:08:51,324 --> 00:08:54,246
SPEAKER_01: And that challenge probably works in both directions, right?

108
00:08:54,647 --> 00:08:59,631
SPEAKER_01: That by them challenging you, it sharpens your ideas or your understanding of your own ideas.

109
00:09:00,051 --> 00:09:04,654
SPEAKER_01: Like I think about this perhaps in a heavy scientific notion where

110
00:09:05,795 --> 00:09:15,097
SPEAKER_01: The first person that said there's bacteria in our hands and we should wash our hands was viewed as someone hallucinating microbes or these weird organisms on our fingers.

111
00:09:15,837 --> 00:09:33,460
SPEAKER_01: So on one hand, we need to be careful with wild imaginary ideas and not treat them as if they're established before they are, but also we need to be able to test novel and breakthrough wild ideas in order to make the moonshot, the cancer moonshot a possibility or something like it.

112
00:09:33,780 --> 00:09:59,785
SPEAKER_00: yeah i guess i guess i never thought about how this is something that policy makers and and maybe doctors have to have in common which is on one hand it's really important to have a sense of conviction and confidence in what you're doing and what you what you believe but you have to balance that conviction with some amount of humility like you could be wrong about anything all of us could be wrong about something right i think part of what's gone haywire in in the the maha stuff and the vaccine skepticism is kind of

113
00:10:01,145 --> 00:10:25,118
SPEAKER_00: capitalizing on this thing that's very valid which is we're never a thousand percent sure about everything and using that to invalidate really sound proven effective ways of helping make people healthier or stopping them from from getting sick and dying yeah it's it's the big notion that i struggle with quite often where as someone who communicates on social media talking about medicine

114
00:10:26,218 --> 00:10:31,822
SPEAKER_01: i have to hedge every conversation whether it's with an individual patient or on a public health scale

115
00:10:32,974 --> 00:10:37,236
SPEAKER_01: to some degree because we don't have 100% certainty in healthcare.

116
00:10:37,857 --> 00:10:39,457
SPEAKER_01: It is an art and a science.

117
00:10:39,677 --> 00:10:49,362
SPEAKER_00: And because you have integrity, you will admit that as a scientist or as a clinician, you admit that, and a lot of the political figures or the conspiracy folks don't admit that there's any uncertainty about what they have to say.

118
00:10:49,382 --> 00:10:53,324
SPEAKER_01: Correct, and that has their message sometimes land more effectively.

119
00:10:54,465 --> 00:11:00,028
SPEAKER_01: So it's like they almost have this tool that we are not using because it's ethical to do so.

120
00:11:00,308 --> 00:11:11,712
SPEAKER_00: But we have an equal and opposite tool, I think, which is that watching people be honest, contend with uncertainty, even revise their thinking over time based on evidence, I think is part of how you earn trust.

121
00:11:11,892 --> 00:11:12,793
SPEAKER_00: That doesn't happen overnight.

122
00:11:13,533 --> 00:11:16,734
SPEAKER_00: But I still believe that doing that in the long run wins out.

123
00:11:16,834 --> 00:11:17,194
SPEAKER_01: I agree.

124
00:11:17,515 --> 00:11:18,455
SPEAKER_01: I think that's really true.

125
00:11:18,875 --> 00:11:29,139
SPEAKER_01: Why do you think folks in the Democratic Party, higher ups, have been so skeptical or nervous about coming into these new formats, Jubilee, podcasts?

126
00:11:29,699 --> 00:11:50,607
SPEAKER_01: uh i know uh vice president kamala harris actually came on our show three days before the election that was a big deal somehow we ended up in her book i didn't expect that both fortunate unfortunate uh because she said her staff didn't prepare her well for the conversation we had um but why is that why is there such a fear of this format i think

127
00:11:51,947 --> 00:11:56,410
SPEAKER_00: generally in my party, for some reason, there's a real allergy to taking risk.

128
00:11:57,471 --> 00:12:02,034
SPEAKER_00: And I mean, everyone in politics has some relationship with risk, maybe some aversion to risk.

129
00:12:02,054 --> 00:12:06,958
SPEAKER_00: You don't want to do something that will undermine your ability to win or your ability to govern.

130
00:12:07,018 --> 00:12:16,744
SPEAKER_00: But I think we've gone way too far to an extreme on that, where because we're afraid of saying something wrong or saying something that's going to get twisted and used against us,

131
00:12:17,585 --> 00:12:24,811
SPEAKER_00: We just don't say very much, or many in my party won't say very much outside of very predictable, comfortable formats.

132
00:12:25,191 --> 00:12:31,957
SPEAKER_00: But it's increasingly the case that people are getting most of their information from alternative or independent media.

133
00:12:32,137 --> 00:12:33,938
SPEAKER_00: And you can love it or hate it, but it's just true.

134
00:12:36,380 --> 00:12:40,702
SPEAKER_00: Right after I came out of the cabinet, I did a stint at the University of Chicago, spent a lot of time with undergraduates.

135
00:12:40,722 --> 00:12:46,065
SPEAKER_00: And I would always do a bit of a show of hands, try to see like, how many of you get your news by watching television on a television?

136
00:12:46,425 --> 00:12:49,227
SPEAKER_00: And the answer was basically zero, right?

137
00:12:49,767 --> 00:12:55,810
SPEAKER_00: And the other thing I would say is, especially these really long form podcasts that go an hour, two, three,

138
00:12:58,951 --> 00:13:06,035
SPEAKER_00: The thing that might be terrifying to a conventional politician is that it is physically impossible to be on talking points for that long.

139
00:13:06,055 --> 00:13:08,096
SPEAKER_00: Just as a matter of stamina, it's not possible.

140
00:13:08,116 --> 00:13:09,957
SPEAKER_00: So you're gonna come off your talking points.

141
00:13:10,217 --> 00:13:18,122
SPEAKER_00: And if you're not comfortable with who you are in those moments in between the things that you and your staff agreed or the things you're gonna say and the way you're gonna say it,

142
00:13:19,122 --> 00:13:20,284
SPEAKER_00: then of course I would be terrified.

143
00:13:20,764 --> 00:13:23,907
SPEAKER_00: So do you think the Democratic Party is not comfortable with who they are?

144
00:13:24,548 --> 00:13:30,473
SPEAKER_00: I think many in the Democratic Party have that habit, but I don't want to say that's true of everybody in the party.

145
00:13:30,493 --> 00:13:34,277
SPEAKER_00: I think many of the most effective voices in the party are more likely to do that.

146
00:13:34,297 --> 00:13:36,880
SPEAKER_00: And of course, there's a generational piece here too, right?

147
00:13:37,600 --> 00:13:51,886
SPEAKER_00: There's whole generations of public figures who came up understanding that the way you connected with people was through speeches that you wrote out and then delivered or short TV appearances that you knew the three questions you were gonna get asked and the seven sentences you had to say.

148
00:13:52,847 --> 00:13:53,827
SPEAKER_00: And it's just different now.

149
00:13:54,147 --> 00:14:00,810
SPEAKER_00: So I think a newer generation is more inclined to take those risks and more comfortable in those formats.

150
00:14:01,130 --> 00:14:01,991
SPEAKER_01: Yeah.

151
00:14:02,111 --> 00:14:11,499
SPEAKER_01: Did you experience any of that from being mayor, smaller town, then going into national politics where you had to expose yourself on that level to have success?

152
00:14:11,519 --> 00:14:12,059
SPEAKER_01: Oh, totally.

153
00:14:12,200 --> 00:14:12,420
SPEAKER_00: Yeah.

154
00:14:12,440 --> 00:14:16,643
SPEAKER_00: So even what you'd call the traditional media had way more access to me as mayor.

155
00:14:16,663 --> 00:14:23,970
SPEAKER_00: So in South Bend, we had four TV stations where South Bend was the largest community in that media market.

156
00:14:24,450 --> 00:14:48,163
SPEAKER_00: and a newspaper uh and an npr station so i knew that somebody was going to if if there was any public question to be asked somebody either from the media or just a neighbor was going to get my face to ask it right sometimes you see these scenes of like a senator kind of walking down the hallway trying to avoid you know the reporters or like ducking into the elevator before anybody could talk to them or they actually get cornered and they don't know what to do

157
00:14:49,463 --> 00:14:53,025
SPEAKER_00: That doesn't happen to mayors because- You're always ready for them.

158
00:14:53,045 --> 00:14:54,025
SPEAKER_00: That's just your life.

159
00:14:54,085 --> 00:14:54,926
SPEAKER_00: That's your daily life.

160
00:14:54,946 --> 00:14:56,046
SPEAKER_00: That's your life.

161
00:14:56,086 --> 00:14:58,007
SPEAKER_00: You go to the grocery store, you're pumping gas.

162
00:14:58,087 --> 00:15:04,250
SPEAKER_00: Somebody's going to come up to you and ask you to explain why you made this decision to change how the trash pickup works or whatever.

163
00:15:04,270 --> 00:15:13,634
SPEAKER_00: So I think you do build a different habit of mind when you're used to being as kind of ridiculously accessible as a lot of local leaders are.

164
00:15:14,434 --> 00:15:18,897
SPEAKER_00: And I would love for there to be more of that in our national politics instead of the other way around.

165
00:15:19,098 --> 00:15:21,119
SPEAKER_01: So more local in our national.

166
00:15:21,239 --> 00:15:21,700
SPEAKER_00: Absolutely.

167
00:15:21,780 --> 00:15:23,241
SPEAKER_00: I think that's important for so many reasons.

168
00:15:23,341 --> 00:15:26,183
SPEAKER_00: I think local government, it's not perfect, but it's less partisan.

169
00:15:26,963 --> 00:15:27,964
SPEAKER_00: It's less predictable.

170
00:15:27,984 --> 00:15:34,529
SPEAKER_00: The factions kind of shift instead of you knowing exactly how some council member is going to vote based on what party they're in.

171
00:15:34,549 --> 00:15:37,271
SPEAKER_00: And it's just more intimate, more immediate.

172
00:15:37,311 --> 00:15:38,972
SPEAKER_00: And there's a clear relationship to results.

173
00:15:39,052 --> 00:15:41,034
SPEAKER_00: I would actually say from a misinformation perspective,

174
00:15:43,069 --> 00:15:56,152
SPEAKER_00: obviously there's rumors and falsehoods at the local level too, but it's much harder for that to carry the day locally because if there's a bunch of potholes, you can't just say, there's no potholes, right?

175
00:15:56,372 --> 00:15:57,612
SPEAKER_00: Of course there are.

176
00:15:57,652 --> 00:16:00,033
SPEAKER_00: You can't just declare that a problem doesn't exist.

177
00:16:00,213 --> 00:16:02,893
SPEAKER_00: You're accountable for some very real hard facts.

178
00:16:03,974 --> 00:16:09,515
SPEAKER_01: What are your feelings on TMZ being now in Capitol Hill and running around Washington, D.C.?

179
00:16:10,575 --> 00:16:12,537
SPEAKER_00: Ambivalent, it's interesting.

180
00:16:12,557 --> 00:16:21,548
SPEAKER_00: I think there's already maybe too much of a weird celebrity culture about how Washington treats politicians, but it's weird to see actual celebrity culture in Canada.

181
00:16:21,609 --> 00:16:25,033
SPEAKER_00: It's usually just within that little circle that people care about.

182
00:16:25,053 --> 00:16:27,396
SPEAKER_01: I've seen them now run up and ask ridiculous questions.

183
00:16:28,677 --> 00:16:52,658
SPEAKER_00: i i feel bad because of that generational divide you talk about where they're asking them questions about some pop culture britney spears news of the day and i'm like oh my god what are they going to even say and they're definitely going to say something wrong yeah but that's where it's fine i think it's really important to just be who you are right because if you get some pop culture question and you know the honest answer as often happens to me with pop culture is like i have no idea like just say it and it's fine

184
00:16:53,118 --> 00:16:59,987
SPEAKER_00: I think where you get into trouble is when you think you have to have a take on everything or you have to know this or that thing or whatever.

185
00:17:00,448 --> 00:17:06,255
SPEAKER_00: Or when you're in one mindset and then you wind up getting pulled into the other.

186
00:17:06,396 --> 00:17:10,401
SPEAKER_00: One time I did get, I think it was a TMZ camera, it was a TMZ style camera anyway.

187
00:17:10,801 --> 00:17:15,922
SPEAKER_00: And I was getting ready to go on a Sunday show, like the ultimate kind of policy television format.

188
00:17:16,463 --> 00:17:17,363
SPEAKER_00: I think it was CBS.

189
00:17:17,383 --> 00:17:18,183
SPEAKER_00: I'm getting out of the car.

190
00:17:18,203 --> 00:17:19,243
SPEAKER_00: I'm going on CBS Sunday morning.

191
00:17:19,263 --> 00:17:23,925
SPEAKER_00: I'm thinking about what I'm gonna say about the president's infrastructure plan and talking points and defend the administration.

192
00:17:23,945 --> 00:17:30,667
SPEAKER_00: And then they catch me and they wanted to ask a question about how Marcus Freeman was doing at Notre Dame as the coach.

193
00:17:31,047 --> 00:17:38,849
SPEAKER_00: And somehow my brain was still in the mode of like, I know if I went back and looked at that game tape, so to speak, it would be me talking as if I was talking about the administration.

194
00:17:39,369 --> 00:17:44,231
SPEAKER_00: When actually all I needed to say was like, I thought he was doing a great job, but you know, it's that kind of thing.

195
00:17:44,791 --> 00:17:44,891
SPEAKER_01: Yeah.

196
00:17:44,931 --> 00:17:52,473
SPEAKER_01: I could see how your mind would have to shift very abruptly in between a very important, serious topic mode to something sillier.

197
00:17:52,533 --> 00:17:53,393
SPEAKER_01: It could be difficult.

198
00:17:53,413 --> 00:17:56,494
SPEAKER_00: Well, especially like, it's easy for me to say like, you should just say what's on your mind.

199
00:17:56,534 --> 00:17:58,295
SPEAKER_00: And that's generally what I try to do.

200
00:17:58,355 --> 00:18:04,997
SPEAKER_00: But look, if you know that if you say a couple of things wrong, like that could move markets, which is true for a cabinet member,

201
00:18:05,277 --> 00:18:14,646
SPEAKER_00: or if you mischaracterize something, even just in the way you phrase it, that could mess up a legislative negotiation or even cause a legal problem.

202
00:18:15,106 --> 00:18:17,909
SPEAKER_00: Of course you learn to think carefully about what you say.

203
00:18:18,029 --> 00:18:20,471
SPEAKER_00: It's just that there's a time and a place for that.

204
00:18:20,712 --> 00:18:26,017
SPEAKER_00: If you're, I don't know, issuing safety guidance, you gotta be hyper careful about the exact words.

205
00:18:26,617 --> 00:18:53,500
SPEAKER_01: versus if you're just trying to introduce yourself as a political figure to a new audience and kind of reveal a little about who you are so that people know who you are enough to appreciate what you have to say it's interesting that there's such a dichotomy between being careful in this way yeah and then on the flip side the flippant version of it where it seems like the secretary of health and human services says anything yeah even when it's just so obviously statistically false

206
00:18:54,853 --> 00:18:56,413
SPEAKER_01: I don't know what the middle ground is.

207
00:18:56,473 --> 00:19:04,275
SPEAKER_01: How do we bring people together here where outright lies are called lies and the truths are called truths?

208
00:19:04,635 --> 00:19:06,876
SPEAKER_01: Are we losing sight of what that middle ground looks like?

209
00:19:06,896 --> 00:19:10,717
SPEAKER_00: Well, I think the middle ground looks like acknowledging when you don't know something, right?

210
00:19:10,817 --> 00:19:18,939
SPEAKER_00: So one thing that you ought to do when you're just shooting the shit on a podcast and somebody asks you about it, I don't know, in my case, it'd probably be some like music or sports thing I don't know anything about.

211
00:19:19,759 --> 00:19:23,540
SPEAKER_00: Or if you're an official in front of Congress and you're getting needled on something,

212
00:19:24,058 --> 00:19:25,059
SPEAKER_00: If you don't know, just say you don't know.

213
00:19:26,381 --> 00:19:30,805
SPEAKER_00: That's definitely the most honest and probably appropriate thing to do in both of those modes.

214
00:19:31,246 --> 00:19:32,888
SPEAKER_01: Well, let me ask you something you definitely know about.

215
00:19:33,589 --> 00:19:36,031
SPEAKER_01: What's it like to be Secretary of Transportation?

216
00:19:36,592 --> 00:19:40,616
SPEAKER_01: And for those of us who are not familiar with that cabinet position, what does that mean?

217
00:19:40,716 --> 00:19:41,858
SPEAKER_01: What are you responsible for?

218
00:19:42,238 --> 00:19:46,440
SPEAKER_00: Well, the things you would naturally think of as kind of planes, trains, and automobiles, right?

219
00:19:47,261 --> 00:19:56,245
SPEAKER_00: And then there's a lot of things that people don't know as much about as part of transportation, like pipeline regulation and safety or running the Merchant Marine Academy.

220
00:19:56,285 --> 00:20:01,428
SPEAKER_00: But I guess I would maybe explain it a different way, which is that the biggest thing you're in charge of is safety.

221
00:20:01,568 --> 00:20:02,508
SPEAKER_00: That's the most important thing.

222
00:20:02,989 --> 00:20:09,172
SPEAKER_00: And whether it's making sure a pipeline doesn't blow up or whether it is the aviation system and the air traffic system,

223
00:20:09,692 --> 00:20:12,573
SPEAKER_00: you're responsible for making it as safe as it can possibly be.

224
00:20:13,353 --> 00:20:15,393
SPEAKER_00: Then there's a whole set of things around infrastructure.

225
00:20:15,673 --> 00:20:33,497
SPEAKER_00: So obviously the big project of the Department of Transportation when I was secretary during the years of the Biden administration was getting this huge infrastructure package delivered that would invest in our railroads and our bridges and our roads and our airports.

226
00:20:33,557 --> 00:20:37,598
SPEAKER_00: And we did about half a trillion dollars that we got passed through.

227
00:20:38,158 --> 00:20:47,304
SPEAKER_00: on everything from these little projects to fix a street corner somewhere to things like the Hudson River Tunnel was one of the biggest public works projects in modern American history.

228
00:20:47,764 --> 00:20:50,266
SPEAKER_00: It would put $16 billion into fixing those tunnels.

229
00:20:51,146 --> 00:20:52,047
SPEAKER_00: So there's that set of things.

230
00:20:52,107 --> 00:21:02,353
SPEAKER_00: And then the third set of things is consumer protection and regulation, which frankly, under some of my predecessors, the department wasn't doing very much, but I thought we could be doing more.

231
00:21:02,513 --> 00:21:06,336
SPEAKER_00: So the biggest example that people know about probably is the airlines or might've heard about.

232
00:21:06,836 --> 00:21:08,859
SPEAKER_00: We found that airlines were not treating passengers well.

233
00:21:09,539 --> 00:21:12,523
SPEAKER_00: We realized that we had a lot of authority over that.

234
00:21:12,984 --> 00:21:17,910
SPEAKER_00: And we pushed the airlines, sometimes with enforcement, sometimes with legislation.

235
00:21:18,451 --> 00:21:20,013
SPEAKER_00: We pushed the airlines to treat people better.

236
00:21:20,033 --> 00:21:23,357
SPEAKER_00: We got people more than a billion dollars of refunds back into their pockets.

237
00:21:24,357 --> 00:21:33,181
SPEAKER_00: We changed what airlines will do if you get stuck in terms of getting you a hotel or ground transportation or food or something if you're stuck and it's their fault.

238
00:21:33,881 --> 00:21:36,383
SPEAKER_00: We made it easier for a refund to come to you without even having to ask.

239
00:21:36,963 --> 00:21:41,485
SPEAKER_00: We pushed them on on-time performance and just having fewer delays and cancellations.

240
00:21:42,165 --> 00:21:46,371
SPEAKER_00: So all of those are part of what a secretary of transportation gets up in the morning and worries about.

241
00:21:46,671 --> 00:21:47,853
SPEAKER_00: First and foremost, it's safety.

242
00:21:48,654 --> 00:21:58,126
SPEAKER_00: But it's all those pieces, keeping the system safe, building the system so it's better for tomorrow, and then making sure all the players in that system, from a trucking company to an airline, are behaving responsibly.

243
00:21:58,747 --> 00:22:11,318
SPEAKER_01: Was there, coming into that position, was there something that you imagined would be an easy, very effective solution that you wanted to implement, but turned out to be way harder, way more difficult to actually have it come to reality?

244
00:22:11,698 --> 00:22:14,500
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, a lot of the infrastructure projects were like that.

245
00:22:15,101 --> 00:22:17,163
SPEAKER_00: You're just thinking, all right, there needs to be a new bridge here.

246
00:22:17,183 --> 00:22:18,944
SPEAKER_00: Let's get rid of the old bridge, put in a new bridge.

247
00:22:19,284 --> 00:22:23,568
SPEAKER_00: Not that I thought it was simple, but it was astonishing to see just how many things

248
00:22:23,688 --> 00:22:26,652
SPEAKER_00: things, red tape, supply chain issues.

249
00:22:27,172 --> 00:22:29,555
SPEAKER_00: Sometimes it had to do with workforce too.

250
00:22:29,856 --> 00:22:33,240
SPEAKER_00: How many things stand in the way of that getting done quickly and affordably?

251
00:22:34,241 --> 00:22:36,924
SPEAKER_00: Took a lot longer than I thought to get the infrastructure package through.

252
00:22:36,944 --> 00:22:40,669
SPEAKER_00: It took most of the first year, even though it was very popular and both sides said they wanted it.

253
00:22:41,149 --> 00:22:42,390
SPEAKER_00: It happened, but it took a lot of push.

254
00:22:42,410 --> 00:22:43,311
SPEAKER_01: What leads to that delay?

255
00:22:43,351 --> 00:22:44,572
SPEAKER_01: Just self-interest?

256
00:22:44,592 --> 00:22:54,219
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, it's a lot of the kind of sausage-making of various senators or House members holding out because they want to see this, but it's the opposite of what one of your other holdouts wants to see.

257
00:22:54,239 --> 00:22:55,600
SPEAKER_00: So you can do more of this, but less of that.

258
00:22:55,620 --> 00:22:57,141
SPEAKER_00: And then you get this vote, and you lose that vote.

259
00:22:57,161 --> 00:22:58,482
SPEAKER_00: I mean, it's really kind of the legislative sausage-making.

260
00:22:58,502 --> 00:23:01,144
SPEAKER_00: So is it like process or persuasion or a hybrid?

261
00:23:01,424 --> 00:23:02,005
SPEAKER_00: It's a lot of that.

262
00:23:02,065 --> 00:23:03,025
SPEAKER_00: And it's resources.

263
00:23:04,146 --> 00:23:06,788
SPEAKER_00: Even in a big department, the DOT has 55,000 people.

264
00:23:07,829 --> 00:23:09,210
SPEAKER_00: But that's not all.

265
00:23:09,370 --> 00:23:09,871
SPEAKER_00: I think there's this...

266
00:23:10,751 --> 00:23:14,516
SPEAKER_00: idea that federal workers are these kind of faceless bureaucrats pushing paper.

267
00:23:14,536 --> 00:23:20,244
SPEAKER_00: I mean, the reality is the single biggest organization within our department was the air traffic organization.

268
00:23:20,284 --> 00:23:22,827
SPEAKER_00: Think of the air traffic controllers, the people who were doing that work.

269
00:23:23,865 --> 00:23:29,227
SPEAKER_00: The other thing that was ferociously hard was modernizing the air traffic control system.

270
00:23:29,427 --> 00:23:31,108
SPEAKER_00: It's something my predecessors had worked on.

271
00:23:31,168 --> 00:23:32,108
SPEAKER_00: It's something I worked on.

272
00:23:32,148 --> 00:23:33,549
SPEAKER_00: It's something my successor was working on.

273
00:23:34,569 --> 00:23:51,315
SPEAKER_00: And when you have a system that is 24 by seven by 365, where there is zero tolerance for failure, built up over decades, billions and billions of dollars going into it, the complexity of getting it to change without any balls being dropped is just enormous.

274
00:23:51,395 --> 00:23:53,356
SPEAKER_00: I knew it would be tough, but it was,

275
00:23:53,876 --> 00:23:55,937
SPEAKER_00: you couple that with some of the dysfunction in Congress.

276
00:23:55,997 --> 00:24:00,858
SPEAKER_00: Like we proposed a multi-billion dollar upgrade for the technology of the FAA.

277
00:24:01,899 --> 00:24:06,320
SPEAKER_00: And Congress didn't pass a budget at all that last year.

278
00:24:06,880 --> 00:24:08,641
SPEAKER_00: So of course we didn't get the funding for that.

279
00:24:09,521 --> 00:24:16,144
SPEAKER_00: So you hit those kind of, that was the most frustrating thing when you have a political cause for what seemed like a technical problem.

280
00:24:16,284 --> 00:24:17,684
SPEAKER_00: You're trying to solve a technical problem.

281
00:24:17,704 --> 00:24:20,045
SPEAKER_00: Like how do we get enough air traffic controllers on station?

282
00:24:20,265 --> 00:24:22,426
SPEAKER_00: Or how do we upgrade this piece of technology?

283
00:24:22,446 --> 00:24:23,486
SPEAKER_00: Or how do we dig this tunnel?

284
00:24:24,648 --> 00:24:32,413
SPEAKER_00: and the technology exists and the knowledge exists, and sometimes even the money exists, but you still can't get the politics sorted out.

285
00:24:32,633 --> 00:24:33,833
SPEAKER_00: That was the really frustrating part.

286
00:24:34,094 --> 00:24:37,896
SPEAKER_01: I mean, that's frustrating, I'm sure, to you being in the driver's seat of that equation.

287
00:24:38,296 --> 00:24:51,684
SPEAKER_01: For people that are watching, that are so frustrated with the bureaucracy of everything, from getting a bathroom built in a city park here, the difficulty, the time, the money, high-speed railroad system in the United States.

288
00:24:52,444 --> 00:24:54,806
SPEAKER_01: That's been talked about for ages now.

289
00:24:54,866 --> 00:24:59,211
SPEAKER_01: It seems like ever since I was in school, that was a potential agenda item for people.

290
00:25:00,372 --> 00:25:02,454
SPEAKER_01: How do we fix that moving forward?

291
00:25:02,594 --> 00:25:08,059
SPEAKER_01: Are there steps that could be taken here or is this just the reality of living in a democracy?

292
00:25:08,139 --> 00:25:14,183
SPEAKER_00: No, this is one of many examples where I think we as a country have tolerated the intolerable.

293
00:25:14,524 --> 00:25:18,406
SPEAKER_00: And one thing that's intolerable is how complicated and expensive it is to build projects.

294
00:25:18,426 --> 00:25:30,195
SPEAKER_00: So we did a lot to change that when I was there, putting a shot clock on some of the bureaucratic processes, saying, look, this has to be done in a year, or if it's incredibly complicated and the law requires it, you still have to try to get it done in two years or less.

295
00:25:31,476 --> 00:25:38,446
SPEAKER_00: trying to cut through just some of the layers of paperwork that went into things, even making the paperwork not paper anymore.

296
00:25:38,486 --> 00:25:42,431
SPEAKER_00: It sounds like super simple stuff, but it hadn't always happened in the federal government.

297
00:25:42,451 --> 00:25:44,173
SPEAKER_01: Believe me, we still have pagers in the hospital.

298
00:25:44,674 --> 00:25:44,955
SPEAKER_01: That's true.

299
00:25:44,975 --> 00:25:45,595
SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I've always wondered.

300
00:25:45,615 --> 00:25:46,437
SPEAKER_01: In fact, maybe you could explain

301
00:25:46,817 --> 00:25:48,958
SPEAKER_00: faxes are still a thing with doctors?

302
00:25:49,018 --> 00:25:53,820
SPEAKER_01: It's because insurance companies probably don't want to upgrade because then they have to pay out more claims quicker.

303
00:25:53,880 --> 00:25:56,221
SPEAKER_00: How can you, I don't know, I just find that astonishing.

304
00:25:56,241 --> 00:25:58,863
SPEAKER_01: The pager thing, I agree there's a reason for it.

305
00:25:59,823 --> 00:26:05,125
SPEAKER_01: If your cell phone loses reception on a floor of the hospital and they can't access you, that's a patient could die.

306
00:26:05,145 --> 00:26:05,486
SPEAKER_01: That makes sense.

307
00:26:05,506 --> 00:26:06,426
SPEAKER_01: So that's like, okay, fine.

308
00:26:06,446 --> 00:26:10,368
SPEAKER_00: But can anybody defend why you keep being asked to fax things when...

309
00:26:10,908 --> 00:26:11,468
SPEAKER_00: That's terrible.

310
00:26:11,568 --> 00:26:12,229
SPEAKER_00: So there is a fix.

311
00:26:12,769 --> 00:26:14,349
SPEAKER_00: But as you know, there's institutional barriers.

312
00:26:14,389 --> 00:26:16,710
SPEAKER_00: But yeah, there's not a simple silver bullet.

313
00:26:16,730 --> 00:26:25,434
SPEAKER_00: But there are many things that can be done, some of which we got done, others of which, if I were king for a day, we would be able to do, that would lower the cost of these things.

314
00:26:25,674 --> 00:26:33,077
SPEAKER_00: And a lot of it is to do with the red tape and all the kind of politics that get in the way of just getting things.

315
00:26:33,137 --> 00:26:34,037
SPEAKER_00: I mean, think about this.

316
00:26:34,457 --> 00:26:36,058
SPEAKER_00: This is not just affecting transportation.

317
00:26:36,398 --> 00:26:36,798
SPEAKER_00: It's part of it.

318
00:26:38,460 --> 00:26:45,145
SPEAKER_00: Congress hasn't actually passed a full budget on time since the 1990s.

319
00:26:46,366 --> 00:26:53,591
SPEAKER_00: So just the most simple thing that any organization, not simple, but one of the most basic things that any organization has to do is to pass a budget.

320
00:26:53,711 --> 00:27:01,597
SPEAKER_00: And in a normal organization, a company, you pass the budget for the year, for example, you lock in that budget before the year starts.

321
00:27:02,592 --> 00:27:04,273
SPEAKER_00: We do it after the fiscal year.

322
00:27:04,313 --> 00:27:08,316
SPEAKER_00: In some parts of government, we still haven't done for this fiscal year that we're like halfway through.

323
00:27:09,416 --> 00:27:11,918
SPEAKER_00: So we're just used to that like it's normal.

324
00:27:12,238 --> 00:27:13,739
SPEAKER_00: And it's one of many examples.

325
00:27:14,860 --> 00:27:15,400
SPEAKER_00: Think of it this way.

326
00:27:16,481 --> 00:27:22,405
SPEAKER_00: If I say the system is broken as a political figure, that would be a totally uninteresting thing for me to say, right?

327
00:27:22,445 --> 00:27:24,666
SPEAKER_00: Like the phrase the system is broken is a cliche.

328
00:27:24,926 --> 00:27:25,627
SPEAKER_00: People say it so much.

329
00:27:26,507 --> 00:27:27,388
SPEAKER_00: Think about what that means.

330
00:27:27,448 --> 00:27:30,909
SPEAKER_00: Like the system is what all of us depend on.

331
00:27:31,910 --> 00:27:34,611
SPEAKER_00: If it's broken, why do we go around acting like it's not broken?

332
00:27:35,551 --> 00:27:40,673
SPEAKER_00: And I see that in the way our, you know, the way money and elections works right now.

333
00:27:41,334 --> 00:27:44,695
SPEAKER_00: I see it in how unrepresentative our Congress is right now.

334
00:27:45,396 --> 00:27:46,616
SPEAKER_00: I see it in our economy right now.

335
00:27:47,096 --> 00:27:53,879
SPEAKER_00: And I think all of those things need to be treated like they're the broken, broken thing that they are.

336
00:27:54,139 --> 00:27:55,120
SPEAKER_00: Too often there's this kind of,

337
00:27:56,349 --> 00:28:00,993
SPEAKER_00: this kind of inertia to just treat them like, well, yeah, we don't like the way it is, but there's no other way.

338
00:28:01,013 --> 00:28:01,573
SPEAKER_00: Of course there is.

339
00:28:01,973 --> 00:28:11,621
SPEAKER_00: People living in other countries have FAT trains, more affordably built infrastructure, more representative government, all the way down to just stuff like, one that really gets me is ID.

340
00:28:12,021 --> 00:28:17,405
SPEAKER_00: So the fact that to prove you are who you say you are in this country, sometimes you need to find

341
00:28:18,756 --> 00:28:23,817
SPEAKER_00: like a birth certificate sitting in a folder in a file drawer of a county health department somewhere.

342
00:28:24,377 --> 00:28:28,318
SPEAKER_00: That they got faxed to them and it's blurry.

343
00:28:30,018 --> 00:28:33,099
SPEAKER_00: You know, your social security card, like this one string of digits.

344
00:28:33,159 --> 00:28:36,079
SPEAKER_00: It's like the most important string of digits in your life.

345
00:28:36,480 --> 00:28:37,760
SPEAKER_00: It's on this flimsy...

346
00:28:38,280 --> 00:28:42,301
SPEAKER_00: Most people in most developed countries have some kind of digital ID system.

347
00:28:42,801 --> 00:28:43,141
SPEAKER_00: We don't.

348
00:28:43,301 --> 00:28:46,061
SPEAKER_00: And we're just used to that, I guess.

349
00:28:46,442 --> 00:28:48,382
SPEAKER_00: We have some serious catching up to do in the U.S.

350
00:28:49,984 --> 00:28:52,366
SPEAKER_01: Who fixes the system?

351
00:28:52,926 --> 00:28:56,428
SPEAKER_01: Is it legislative branch, executive?

352
00:28:56,888 --> 00:28:58,269
SPEAKER_01: Does Supreme Court play a role here?

353
00:28:58,649 --> 00:28:59,630
SPEAKER_00: All of them need change.

354
00:29:00,350 --> 00:29:08,776
SPEAKER_00: So when I was running for president almost eight years ago, I proposed structural change to the Supreme Court because I think it has lost legitimacy.

355
00:29:09,156 --> 00:29:19,282
SPEAKER_00: It's viewed as a partisan institution, and that is incredibly dangerous because we need our Supreme Court to be something that everybody, love or hate the decision, believes to be legitimate.

356
00:29:19,522 --> 00:29:35,506
SPEAKER_00: And there were reforms you could make so that you didn't have this kind of grotesque scenario of people hanging on way longer and older than they should be there to time their departure from the bench so that when the same party is in power, we don't have to have that.

357
00:29:36,646 --> 00:29:38,006
SPEAKER_00: Congress definitely needs to change.

358
00:29:38,486 --> 00:29:40,927
SPEAKER_00: We've got 435 seats in the House.

359
00:29:41,707 --> 00:29:44,107
SPEAKER_00: Roughly 40 of them are considered competitive.

360
00:29:44,908 --> 00:29:46,848
SPEAKER_00: So one out of 10 House elections

361
00:29:47,815 --> 00:29:53,477
SPEAKER_00: is one where you actually don't know who's gonna win before election day in a 50-50 country.

362
00:29:53,998 --> 00:29:54,558
SPEAKER_00: That is nuts.

363
00:29:55,218 --> 00:29:57,179
SPEAKER_00: Of course, it's not representing us if that's how it's set up.

364
00:29:57,199 --> 00:30:01,421
SPEAKER_01: Is that because people separate into groups that agree with one another or it's a bigger issue?

365
00:30:01,441 --> 00:30:04,582
SPEAKER_00: No, it's because they are separated from each other on these crazy maps.

366
00:30:04,622 --> 00:30:06,583
SPEAKER_00: I mean, yes, in some cases, sure.

367
00:30:06,703 --> 00:30:14,926
SPEAKER_00: If you got a one-seat election in a place like Vermont compared to a place like Alaska, the politics are different, sure.

368
00:30:16,682 --> 00:30:20,086
SPEAKER_00: But the gerrymandering is out of control.

369
00:30:20,146 --> 00:30:24,451
SPEAKER_00: And now it's this arms race where one side does it so the other side feels they have to do it to compensate for it.

370
00:30:24,471 --> 00:30:27,255
SPEAKER_00: So until we have less of that, and that's just one of the problems.

371
00:30:27,295 --> 00:30:29,037
SPEAKER_00: Money in politics, huge problem.

372
00:30:29,197 --> 00:30:29,778
SPEAKER_00: Everybody hates it.

373
00:30:30,478 --> 00:30:34,984
SPEAKER_00: The problem, of course, with all of these things about our system is you have to use the system

374
00:30:35,595 --> 00:30:39,217
SPEAKER_00: You know, the only legal way to deal with it is to go into the system to change the system.

375
00:30:39,377 --> 00:30:42,659
SPEAKER_00: But we've done that before as a country many, many, many times.

376
00:30:43,000 --> 00:30:49,484
SPEAKER_00: I mean, people sometimes forget that many of the ways we set up our election, they're not in the Constitution.

377
00:30:50,064 --> 00:30:50,885
SPEAKER_00: They're in law.

378
00:30:51,285 --> 00:30:52,826
SPEAKER_00: Those laws could change and be better.

379
00:30:53,426 --> 00:30:55,427
SPEAKER_00: And some of the things that are in the Constitution we changed.

380
00:30:55,447 --> 00:30:56,768
SPEAKER_00: We didn't used to get to vote for senators.

381
00:30:57,369 --> 00:30:59,170
SPEAKER_00: They were picked out by a legislature.

382
00:30:59,810 --> 00:31:01,792
SPEAKER_00: Then we were like, no, we should get to vote on who our senators are.

383
00:31:01,812 --> 00:31:02,613
SPEAKER_00: They changed the Constitution.

384
00:31:03,073 --> 00:31:15,423
SPEAKER_00: So this idea that you couldn't possibly do anything that required a reform like a constitutional amendment is something we've kind of sleepwalked into when the reality is, you know, we have amended the Constitution almost 30 times.

385
00:31:16,043 --> 00:31:18,686
SPEAKER_00: Sometimes we've changed our mind about an amendment.

386
00:31:18,726 --> 00:31:19,546
SPEAKER_00: Prohibition, right?

387
00:31:19,827 --> 00:31:23,389
SPEAKER_00: We changed the entire Constitution so that you couldn't get a drink.

388
00:31:24,510 --> 00:31:26,512
SPEAKER_00: And then we changed our mind and we changed it back.

389
00:31:27,365 --> 00:31:38,594
SPEAKER_00: Don't tell me we can't change the constitution to clarify on money and politics, for example, that a corporation is not the same thing as a person and that manipulating an election with money is not the same thing as ordinary speech.

390
00:31:39,095 --> 00:31:41,336
SPEAKER_00: We just need to take bigger swings when it comes to reform.

391
00:31:42,277 --> 00:31:48,002
SPEAKER_01: You mentioned earlier that if you were king for a day, you would make certain changes in the DOT.

392
00:31:49,747 --> 00:31:57,540
SPEAKER_01: President Trump has used executive actions to make all sorts of rules, essentially, as some would say, a king might.

393
00:31:58,688 --> 00:32:07,294
SPEAKER_01: Do you feel like that is a valuable use of power, perhaps not for the decisions he's made, but do you like the way the executive branch is going about that?

394
00:32:07,334 --> 00:32:09,656
SPEAKER_01: Is that something you'd like to see more of or less of in the future?

395
00:32:09,716 --> 00:32:12,818
SPEAKER_00: Well, I don't like it because I think it's mostly illegal.

396
00:32:13,879 --> 00:32:21,865
SPEAKER_00: But there is an important point that I think my political party could learn from, which is they're doing lots of big things at the same time.

397
00:32:22,545 --> 00:32:25,327
SPEAKER_00: And they're looking through all of the tools in the toolkits

398
00:32:26,925 --> 00:32:29,246
SPEAKER_00: and picking up every tool they can to get their agenda done.

399
00:32:29,366 --> 00:32:36,370
SPEAKER_00: Again, I wouldn't emulate the agenda, obviously, and I wouldn't emulate the illegal behavior, because a lot of the things they've done, then they get beaten back in court.

400
00:32:36,830 --> 00:32:42,613
SPEAKER_00: But we did take a bit of an approach like this, again, when it came to things where we'd just been banging our heads against the wall, like getting results out of the airlines.

401
00:32:43,273 --> 00:32:53,378
SPEAKER_00: So at one point, the kind of department lawyers came to me on this case where an airline was holding out on hundreds of millions of dollars of refunds.

402
00:32:54,674 --> 00:33:01,099
SPEAKER_00: And they said, you know, we're going to get them to finally pay it back because they're legally required to, and there's going to be a fine of a couple of million dollars.

403
00:33:01,620 --> 00:33:04,362
SPEAKER_00: I said, well, I don't think that fine really had much of an effect.

404
00:33:04,382 --> 00:33:05,243
SPEAKER_00: So what if you add a zero?

405
00:33:05,983 --> 00:33:08,265
SPEAKER_00: And it turns out we had the authority to just add a zero.

406
00:33:08,585 --> 00:33:10,687
SPEAKER_00: And if they disagreed, to make it 10 times the fine.

407
00:33:11,187 --> 00:33:12,488
SPEAKER_00: If they disagreed, they could take us to court.

408
00:33:12,889 --> 00:33:15,851
SPEAKER_00: And we started doing much more aggressive enforcement actions.

409
00:33:16,572 --> 00:33:19,194
SPEAKER_00: And what happened was the airlines did not take us to court.

410
00:33:19,214 --> 00:33:21,616
SPEAKER_00: They settled with us because they knew we were on solid ground.

411
00:33:22,396 --> 00:33:47,099
SPEAKER_00: other times we didn't actually have to use these big kind of big guns of federal policy we use transparency so we set up a website that just you can still find it it's called flightrights.gov i don't my successor is a was an airline lobbyist so he's obviously less interested in enforcing customer service regulations on airlines but i don't think he took this down if you go to flightrights.gov you can see this list

412
00:33:47,679 --> 00:33:54,103
SPEAKER_00: little green check marks, little red Xs, kind of issue by issue on which airlines have which protections.

413
00:33:54,364 --> 00:33:58,667
SPEAKER_00: If you get stuck, do they get you dinner?

414
00:33:58,707 --> 00:34:00,548
SPEAKER_00: Do they get you ground transportation?

415
00:34:00,568 --> 00:34:01,529
SPEAKER_00: Do they pay for your hotel?

416
00:34:01,549 --> 00:34:02,850
SPEAKER_00: Will they book you on another airline?

417
00:34:03,730 --> 00:34:07,393
SPEAKER_00: And what we did was we decided to put that information out.

418
00:34:08,351 --> 00:34:11,512
SPEAKER_00: But first we told all the airlines that we were gonna put that information out.

419
00:34:11,712 --> 00:34:17,114
SPEAKER_00: We said, why don't you look into your customer service plans and see if there's anything you wanna change before we make it really easy to find.

420
00:34:17,154 --> 00:34:18,395
SPEAKER_00: And a lot of them did.

421
00:34:18,655 --> 00:34:25,557
SPEAKER_00: A lot of them actually changed their policies because they knew we were gonna make it easier for a passenger to check their policies.

422
00:34:25,978 --> 00:34:26,958
SPEAKER_00: So here you have an example

423
00:34:29,138 --> 00:34:30,319
SPEAKER_00: Didn't take an act of Congress.

424
00:34:30,339 --> 00:34:32,179
SPEAKER_00: It wasn't an enforcement action.

425
00:34:32,199 --> 00:34:33,240
SPEAKER_00: We didn't have to take anybody to court.

426
00:34:33,260 --> 00:34:34,640
SPEAKER_00: You were thinking like an influencer, a disruptor.

427
00:34:34,781 --> 00:34:35,841
SPEAKER_00: I suppose, yeah, yeah.

428
00:34:35,921 --> 00:34:37,502
SPEAKER_00: We're just putting good information out there.

429
00:34:37,542 --> 00:34:39,603
SPEAKER_00: But the point is you've got to do both, or you've got to do all of the above.

430
00:34:39,783 --> 00:34:43,484
SPEAKER_00: You've got to use all the tools that you have legally to get big changes through.

431
00:34:44,125 --> 00:34:45,905
SPEAKER_00: And when you do that, you get results.

432
00:34:46,126 --> 00:34:51,688
SPEAKER_00: And I think we should learn to be more creative legally, sound, ethical,

433
00:34:52,503 --> 00:35:00,169
SPEAKER_00: but creative about how to take all these tools that are in the law and in the different levels of government and use them to get results for people.

434
00:35:00,189 --> 00:35:20,785
SPEAKER_00: Because the whole point of government is to make your everyday life better, whether it's as an airline passenger or as a worker or as a consumer or as a parent, like the job of the federal government is to use whatever tools it has to tear down the barriers that stand between you and a better life.

435
00:35:21,686 --> 00:35:30,318
SPEAKER_01: You mentioned airlines and my heart had multiple palpitations because of the state that our airline system is currently in.

436
00:35:30,899 --> 00:35:35,445
SPEAKER_01: Delays, deaths, dangerous near misses.

437
00:35:36,727 --> 00:35:37,628
SPEAKER_01: Why do you think this is happening?

438
00:35:38,449 --> 00:35:46,336
SPEAKER_00: Well, a lot of reasons have gone into that, and I can't speak to everything that's going on under my successor because I've been out of that office for a while.

439
00:35:47,837 --> 00:35:58,126
SPEAKER_00: But I am concerned about a lot of areas in transportation, especially actually in rail and surface transportation, where some rules are being softened that have to do with safety.

440
00:35:59,086 --> 00:36:01,807
SPEAKER_00: On air travel, you could tell two different stories that are both true.

441
00:36:02,367 --> 00:36:06,369
SPEAKER_00: One, I'm very concerned about the near misses and obviously the tragedies that have happened recently.

442
00:36:07,109 --> 00:36:13,071
SPEAKER_00: And again, being on the outside, I don't know as much about some of the details that investigators know or that the department knows.

443
00:36:13,171 --> 00:36:15,112
SPEAKER_00: Do you talk with Secretary Duffy?

444
00:36:15,632 --> 00:36:16,832
SPEAKER_00: I reached out to him when he got the job.

445
00:36:17,333 --> 00:36:21,054
SPEAKER_00: We had one conversation, a couple of conversations during the transition.

446
00:36:21,074 --> 00:36:23,735
SPEAKER_00: We haven't really kept in touch since.

447
00:36:25,775 --> 00:36:26,716
SPEAKER_00: But I'll also say this.

448
00:36:27,972 --> 00:36:36,999
SPEAKER_00: Aviation is the, commercial aviation, like just being on an airliner, like I was today on my way up here, the safest way to get somewhere in this country by far.

449
00:36:37,560 --> 00:36:38,360
SPEAKER_00: It's not even close.

450
00:36:39,962 --> 00:36:45,646
SPEAKER_00: During the time I was secretary, we had 4 billion employments, 4 billion times a passenger got on a plane.

451
00:36:46,683 --> 00:36:50,744
SPEAKER_00: And out of those, the number of crash fatalities from commercial airliners was zero.

452
00:36:50,884 --> 00:36:52,004
SPEAKER_00: Zero out of four billion.

453
00:36:53,085 --> 00:37:03,827
SPEAKER_00: There are very few other things you can do in your life four billion times, including walking across the street or even eating a meal without a fatality.

454
00:37:04,487 --> 00:37:05,588
SPEAKER_00: And that didn't just happen.

455
00:37:05,608 --> 00:37:08,148
SPEAKER_00: That happened because of rules, technology, people.

456
00:37:09,629 --> 00:37:10,889
SPEAKER_00: And it takes a lot to keep it that way.

457
00:37:12,040 --> 00:37:27,985
SPEAKER_00: But what's really strange about the human mind is while we all notice anytime there's any deviation from that safety record on aviation, we're weirdly tolerant of a terrible safety record on driving.

458
00:37:28,985 --> 00:37:35,187
SPEAKER_00: So today, enough people will die in car crashes to fill a 737.

459
00:37:35,407 --> 00:37:38,848
SPEAKER_00: And that happened yesterday, and that'll happen tomorrow.

460
00:37:39,848 --> 00:37:45,670
SPEAKER_00: And a top priority for me was to reverse the rise in roadway deaths that we had experienced as a country.

461
00:37:45,730 --> 00:37:47,510
SPEAKER_00: And we did, we brought it down.

462
00:37:47,951 --> 00:37:48,451
SPEAKER_00: How do you do that?

463
00:37:48,471 --> 00:37:49,891
SPEAKER_00: A lot of things.

464
00:37:49,931 --> 00:37:51,692
SPEAKER_00: Part of it's the way that the roads are designed.

465
00:37:52,012 --> 00:37:55,033
SPEAKER_00: It actually really matters whether the way, even just the shape of the lane.

466
00:37:55,073 --> 00:37:57,934
SPEAKER_01: Like those little barriers on the sides or the sound.

467
00:37:59,134 --> 00:38:04,238
SPEAKER_00: Bump-outs on a busy street kind of make the car slow down and look around a little bit more.

468
00:38:05,079 --> 00:38:11,764
SPEAKER_00: Two-way streets, sometimes, not everywhere, but often can be safer than a one-way pattern, at least for pedestrians.

469
00:38:13,305 --> 00:38:20,791
SPEAKER_00: Roundabouts, actually, people are sometimes annoyed by them if they get installed in a place where you're not used to them, but you often see a dramatic reduction in serious injury.

470
00:38:20,811 --> 00:38:25,295
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, because at a roundabout, it's almost impossible to have a head-on collision or get T-boned.

471
00:38:25,595 --> 00:38:27,816
SPEAKER_00: So you may have fender benders, but it's less likely to be fatal.

472
00:38:29,878 --> 00:38:41,645
SPEAKER_00: Again, all of this depends on the place and the situation, but we put a lot of dollars, a lot of federal dollars out of that infrastructure package into projects that communities wanted to do, had wanted to do for a long time.

473
00:38:41,665 --> 00:38:46,908
SPEAKER_00: And I knew as a mayor, I knew what it was like to have had 12 different places around the city where I wanted to make road improvements.

474
00:38:46,928 --> 00:38:47,708
SPEAKER_00: We just didn't have the money.

475
00:38:48,208 --> 00:38:50,670
SPEAKER_00: We got the money to the communities to make those kinds of improvements.

476
00:38:51,110 --> 00:38:53,771
SPEAKER_00: So there's road design, there's technology.

477
00:38:54,311 --> 00:38:55,711
SPEAKER_00: Technology is kind of cut both ways.

478
00:38:56,231 --> 00:39:03,933
SPEAKER_00: On one hand, cars are a lot safer and we took steps to require things like automatic emergency braking, right?

479
00:39:03,993 --> 00:39:05,254
SPEAKER_00: That just wasn't there a few years ago.

480
00:39:05,954 --> 00:39:09,515
SPEAKER_00: On the other hand, distracted driving is a huge issue.

481
00:39:09,976 --> 00:39:15,145
SPEAKER_00: And there are a lot of things that take people's eye or their mind off of the road right now, which is often fatal.

482
00:39:17,329 --> 00:39:17,890
SPEAKER_00: There's behavior.

483
00:39:18,371 --> 00:39:19,272
SPEAKER_00: There's what people actually do.

484
00:39:19,292 --> 00:39:21,837
SPEAKER_00: So you have to have safer people.

485
00:39:23,470 --> 00:39:25,391
SPEAKER_00: You can make the vehicles themselves safer.

486
00:39:26,212 --> 00:39:30,155
SPEAKER_00: All of these things kind of interact with each other to affect roadway safety.

487
00:39:30,775 --> 00:39:43,986
SPEAKER_00: Probably the most important safety development, we have to make sure it develops the right way, is automated vehicles, which look, there are a lot of situations where apples to apples, it's already the case that a self-driving car is safer than you or I would be behind the wheel.

488
00:39:44,286 --> 00:39:50,431
SPEAKER_00: That's hard to admit, because the average driver believes that they are safer than the average driver, but it's increasingly true.

489
00:39:51,031 --> 00:39:52,893
SPEAKER_00: at least under the conditions where they're being tested.

490
00:39:53,914 --> 00:40:00,560
SPEAKER_00: And what I know is that we cannot keep accepting the idea that we lose almost 40,000 people a year.

491
00:40:01,161 --> 00:40:03,423
SPEAKER_00: It's the same as gun violence in terms of the body count.

492
00:40:04,607 --> 00:40:22,586
SPEAKER_00: and act like there's nothing we can do about it, while this other form of transportation, flying, where you were propelled through the air in a tube at nearly the speed of light, miles above the surface of the ground, propelled, I might add, by flammable liquids, right, can go a year or two or three or 10 with zero airliner crash fatalities.

493
00:40:24,539 --> 00:40:31,031
SPEAKER_01: So what is Secretary Duffy doing now that's creating or allowing the situation to devolve as it is now?

494
00:40:31,672 --> 00:40:35,119
SPEAKER_01: Because right now it's really bad in terms of delays and-

495
00:40:35,440 --> 00:40:40,684
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so I don't know as much about kind of the inner workings of the department as I used to.

496
00:40:40,764 --> 00:40:50,812
SPEAKER_00: What I will say is that when we had a lot of delays, we really pushed the airlines and let them know that we were going to hold them accountable for what, especially if it was something we thought they could control.

497
00:40:51,012 --> 00:40:51,552
SPEAKER_00: And they hated it.

498
00:40:51,753 --> 00:41:03,041
SPEAKER_00: I mean, I remember in particular a very direct, pretty blunt conversation with the CEO of Delta Airlines after they had a meltdown that left a lot of their passengers stranded.

499
00:41:04,262 --> 00:41:08,186
SPEAKER_00: He was upset with me because I was holding them accountable as an airline.

500
00:41:08,226 --> 00:41:15,192
SPEAKER_00: And he said, my customer service people are getting really hot treatment right now because of this.

501
00:41:15,212 --> 00:41:17,094
SPEAKER_00: And I said, no, it's not because we're holding you accountable.

502
00:41:17,114 --> 00:41:19,035
SPEAKER_00: It's because you let your customers down.

503
00:41:19,916 --> 00:41:21,357
SPEAKER_00: They're not mad because of something I did.

504
00:41:21,397 --> 00:41:24,720
SPEAKER_00: They're mad because of what you guys did or didn't do.

505
00:41:24,740 --> 00:41:26,722
SPEAKER_00: And Southwest had this big meltdown.

506
00:41:27,302 --> 00:41:29,144
SPEAKER_00: We held them accountable with a major enforcement action.

507
00:41:29,444 --> 00:41:36,390
SPEAKER_00: Now, Secretary Duffy has actually reversed some of the enforcement, some of the things that they were required to do under our settlement.

508
00:41:36,871 --> 00:41:49,862
SPEAKER_00: So I do worry that if you take your foot off the gas on that kind of enforcement, that does make the airlines think, okay, maybe we don't have to work quite as hard to take care of our systems and our passengers.

509
00:41:50,522 --> 00:42:02,481
SPEAKER_00: the other thing that i think is a real problem is that the industry has just gotten less and less competitive when they deregulated the airlines and created the system we have now this was decades ago they thought there would be dozens of airlines

510
00:42:03,849 --> 00:42:12,957
SPEAKER_00: And right now it's possible that just between when you and I are sitting here and when this podcast drops, there could be another consolidation where we have even fewer airlines than we used to have.

511
00:42:13,777 --> 00:42:25,407
SPEAKER_00: And as with any industry, the less competition you have, the fewer airlines or the fewer companies you have competing against each other, the more you have trouble with actually getting good outcomes.

512
00:42:26,027 --> 00:42:30,971
SPEAKER_01: So when JetBlue and Spirit were trying to come together, what were your feelings on that?

513
00:42:31,304 --> 00:42:37,366
SPEAKER_00: Well, our feelings about it were that it probably violated the law and would make customers worse off.

514
00:42:37,526 --> 00:42:46,250
SPEAKER_00: And again, you had some of these airlines trying to say, well, unless we have yet another merger, there's just no way that we can survive.

515
00:42:46,911 --> 00:42:50,873
SPEAKER_00: And you have to really ask, what is that saying about your industry and about your airline?

516
00:42:50,913 --> 00:42:55,695
SPEAKER_00: That the only way you could possibly stay in business is if you combine with another airline.

517
00:42:55,895 --> 00:42:57,776
SPEAKER_00: Now, that doesn't mean we never allowed mergers.

518
00:42:57,816 --> 00:43:07,840
SPEAKER_00: There was one between Alaska and Hawaii, for example, where we held them to a very strict standard that said, look, we need to see these things that show us that you're going to make passengers and customers better off.

519
00:43:08,320 --> 00:43:12,222
SPEAKER_00: If you can do that, then you'll meet kind of our legal criteria.

520
00:43:13,386 --> 00:43:15,112
SPEAKER_00: And they did, and we signed off.

521
00:43:15,514 --> 00:43:17,120
SPEAKER_00: But with JetBlue and Spirit, it just didn't add up.

522
00:43:19,503 --> 00:43:27,004
SPEAKER_01: talking about these types of consolidations that are trying to happen in the airline industry, I see it happening in the healthcare industry.

523
00:43:28,305 --> 00:43:30,885
SPEAKER_01: And it's absolutely destructive in so many ways.

524
00:43:31,025 --> 00:43:36,466
SPEAKER_01: And I want to talk to you about healthcare, because obviously, Healthcare Checkup podcast.

525
00:43:37,066 --> 00:43:47,888
SPEAKER_01: But I'm curious about your relationship to healthcare, perhaps as former cabinet member, as a mayor, maybe even more importantly, a father.

526
00:43:49,433 --> 00:43:50,779
SPEAKER_01: What is your relationship with healthcare?

527
00:43:50,919 --> 00:43:53,611
SPEAKER_01: How do you gauge the United States is doing on that front?

528
00:43:54,073 --> 00:44:09,279
SPEAKER_00: Well, I guess like most people, I mean, my relationship, my most important relationship with healthcare is as a human being, and have really been plunged into some pretty intense experiences, especially as a parent.

529
00:44:09,659 --> 00:44:19,183
SPEAKER_00: So, the encounter with healthcare that was the most dramatic in my life was when our twins who were just infants,

530
00:44:19,683 --> 00:44:20,944
SPEAKER_00: became ill with RSV.

531
00:44:22,225 --> 00:44:24,487
SPEAKER_00: As you know, RSV is this respiratory virus.

532
00:44:24,567 --> 00:44:26,028
SPEAKER_00: If you and I get it, it's a bad cold.

533
00:44:26,088 --> 00:44:28,450
SPEAKER_00: If an infant gets it, it's life-threatening.

534
00:44:28,710 --> 00:44:36,617
SPEAKER_01: Yeah, much smaller airways, an immune system that has never seen the virus, so it doesn't have a memory of all the cells that can come to its aid.

535
00:44:38,058 --> 00:44:45,844
SPEAKER_01: Historically, any time a child gets their first case of RSV, pretty much any virus, but specifically RSV, it's always the worst case.

536
00:44:45,924 --> 00:44:47,465
SPEAKER_01: The next one is always a little bit easier.

537
00:44:48,386 --> 00:44:51,947
SPEAKER_01: partially because the airways are larger, but also because of that immune memory component.

538
00:44:52,387 --> 00:44:54,648
SPEAKER_01: So I can only imagine how scary it must have been.

539
00:44:55,268 --> 00:44:56,288
SPEAKER_01: What was that scenario like?

540
00:44:56,328 --> 00:44:56,848
SPEAKER_01: What happened?

541
00:44:56,968 --> 00:44:58,469
SPEAKER_01: How did you find out that they were that ill?

542
00:44:58,649 --> 00:45:06,771
SPEAKER_00: Well, at first we just noticed, I mean, they were just a few weeks old, and both of them seemed like they were sick in some way.

543
00:45:09,131 --> 00:45:14,973
SPEAKER_00: But especially with our son, Gus, it wasn't just that he was coughing.

544
00:45:14,993 --> 00:45:15,353
SPEAKER_00: It was this

545
00:45:17,267 --> 00:45:20,812
SPEAKER_00: You could see his belly was like going in and out.

546
00:45:20,852 --> 00:45:23,054
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's the word the doctors used.

547
00:45:24,396 --> 00:45:26,979
SPEAKER_00: And they talked about these retractions.

548
00:45:27,020 --> 00:45:28,501
SPEAKER_00: I think they called it the work of breathing.

549
00:45:28,722 --> 00:45:30,444
SPEAKER_00: Like the work of breathing was too much.

550
00:45:30,851 --> 00:45:36,635
SPEAKER_01: Yeah, we look for the ribs to be doing the accessory breathing, using accessory muscles to breathe, but also the neck.

551
00:45:37,476 --> 00:45:46,882
SPEAKER_01: So if a child's like really struggling to get air in and their typical diaphragmatic muscles are fatiguing, they start using this accessory muscle and that's where we start getting concerned.

552
00:45:47,182 --> 00:45:57,790
SPEAKER_01: And what's unique about children, even more so for infants, is that they have a propensity to decompensate very quickly because they have low reserve.

553
00:45:59,005 --> 00:46:05,347
SPEAKER_01: As adults, we have a higher reserve in terms of immune system performance, blood flow, immune cell support.

554
00:46:05,767 --> 00:46:06,247
SPEAKER_01: They don't.

555
00:46:07,047 --> 00:46:10,609
SPEAKER_01: At the same time, what's interesting about them, they also bounce back quite quickly.

556
00:46:11,109 --> 00:46:19,491
SPEAKER_01: So that's what my difficulty is in being a family medicine doctor is when I see a child, I need to make the distinction of in which direction are they going?

557
00:46:20,111 --> 00:46:23,272
SPEAKER_01: Because what I see now can be totally different tomorrow.

558
00:46:23,332 --> 00:46:25,213
SPEAKER_01: It could be much worse or much better.

559
00:46:25,853 --> 00:46:28,755
SPEAKER_01: And that's what makes it very difficult to know what to do in those scenarios.

560
00:46:28,775 --> 00:46:29,436
SPEAKER_01: So I'm curious how it played out.

561
00:46:29,456 --> 00:46:30,557
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's exactly what happened with us.

562
00:46:30,597 --> 00:46:32,598
SPEAKER_00: So both of them were ill enough they had to go to the hospital.

563
00:46:32,718 --> 00:46:33,779
SPEAKER_00: They put them on oxygen.

564
00:46:33,979 --> 00:46:35,440
SPEAKER_00: And you're a parent.

565
00:46:35,841 --> 00:46:37,182
SPEAKER_00: These are your infant children.

566
00:46:37,202 --> 00:46:38,843
SPEAKER_00: We were new parents.

567
00:46:38,943 --> 00:46:40,624
SPEAKER_00: We didn't know what was normal.

568
00:46:40,644 --> 00:46:42,906
SPEAKER_00: We were still just figuring out how to be parents.

569
00:46:42,966 --> 00:46:43,627
SPEAKER_00: My husband and I were.

570
00:46:44,988 --> 00:46:47,310
SPEAKER_01: Where were you in terms of job at that time?

571
00:46:47,610 --> 00:46:48,671
SPEAKER_00: I was secretary.

572
00:46:49,832 --> 00:46:52,355
SPEAKER_00: And I had taken a parental leave.

573
00:46:52,375 --> 00:46:54,737
SPEAKER_00: I was encouraging our employees to do that.

574
00:46:55,498 --> 00:47:00,322
SPEAKER_00: Federal employees have leave, so I wanted to do the same thing, lead by example.

575
00:47:00,362 --> 00:47:08,270
SPEAKER_00: Obviously, I was available for emergencies, but I thought it was important both to my family and as kind of the leader of the department to set the right example.

576
00:47:08,950 --> 00:47:15,772
SPEAKER_00: as a father and take the leave that I think every parent should be able to do and that every federal worker thankfully has the right to do.

577
00:47:18,952 --> 00:47:24,474
SPEAKER_00: But I thought it would be feeding them and getting through the sleep.

578
00:47:24,514 --> 00:47:27,174
SPEAKER_00: And it was, all those things you're just figuring out with bottles and diapers.

579
00:47:27,854 --> 00:47:30,095
SPEAKER_00: And suddenly we're dealing with this and they're both in the hospital.

580
00:47:30,580 --> 00:47:35,081
SPEAKER_00: And they both had these little like cannulas around their little faces, you know, on oxygen.

581
00:47:35,662 --> 00:47:37,862
SPEAKER_00: And then kind of like you were saying, our daughter started getting better.

582
00:47:37,902 --> 00:47:41,363
SPEAKER_00: She just kind of popped back and he started to seem to get better too.

583
00:47:41,383 --> 00:47:43,664
SPEAKER_00: I thought we were out of the woods, but then he starts getting worse.

584
00:47:44,944 --> 00:47:47,065
SPEAKER_00: And to me, it was scary enough to be in the hospital.

585
00:47:47,325 --> 00:47:54,007
SPEAKER_00: But then I remember all of these kind of doctors and staff kind of coming in and out of the room.

586
00:47:54,027 --> 00:47:56,228
SPEAKER_00: And it felt like they were just, every time there was like more of them.

587
00:47:57,268 --> 00:47:59,650
SPEAKER_00: And I mean, I can't describe how tiny he was.

588
00:47:59,930 --> 00:48:08,234
SPEAKER_00: I mean, I don't think he was 10 pounds yet and just feeling totally powerless, like just not knowing what was going to happen next.

589
00:48:08,795 --> 00:48:15,539
SPEAKER_00: And what happened next was he started getting worse and they did more oxygen, you know, two liters, four liters, however high it goes.

590
00:48:15,559 --> 00:48:20,822
SPEAKER_00: I don't know, but, but they're putting more and more oxygen into him and he's not getting better.

591
00:48:21,822 --> 00:48:26,625
SPEAKER_00: And you're trying to understand what, you know, what these numbers and these things they're,

592
00:48:27,383 --> 00:48:30,425
SPEAKER_00: I'm an educated guy, but I don't know about this stuff.

593
00:48:31,045 --> 00:48:32,046
SPEAKER_00: And you're trying to make sense of it.

594
00:48:32,106 --> 00:48:33,867
SPEAKER_00: And emotional and sleep deprived and all those factors.

595
00:48:33,887 --> 00:48:34,847
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and you haven't slept.

596
00:48:34,907 --> 00:48:39,510
SPEAKER_00: And then at a certain point, they said, we have to intubate him.

597
00:48:39,670 --> 00:48:41,891
SPEAKER_00: We're going to have to put him on a respirator so he can breathe.

598
00:48:42,292 --> 00:48:47,635
SPEAKER_00: And I remember the doctor saying, you might want to step out of the room for this because it's not a nice procedure.

599
00:48:48,715 --> 00:48:49,316
SPEAKER_00: And we did.

600
00:48:49,336 --> 00:48:53,458
SPEAKER_00: And I remember Chastin and me just hugging each other in the hallway, wondering what's going to happen next.

601
00:48:54,569 --> 00:48:59,413
SPEAKER_00: And we live in a smaller town, Traverse City, Michigan, and they wanted to get him to a bigger hospital.

602
00:48:59,573 --> 00:49:06,219
SPEAKER_00: So they said, he's gotta go to Grand Rapids, where there's a big, great children's hospital.

603
00:49:08,842 --> 00:49:12,603
SPEAKER_00: they wanted to use a helicopter, the weather was too bad, so they put him in an ambulance.

604
00:49:12,643 --> 00:49:28,387
SPEAKER_00: So Chasten is in this ambulance for a couple of hours with Gus, like racing down to Grand Rapids while I went home to relieve my mother-in-law, who's keeping an eye on our daughter and realized I gotta get her down to Grand Rapids so we can all be in one place as a family.

605
00:49:29,167 --> 00:49:34,648
SPEAKER_00: And then by the time I got there, I walk into the room in the ICU and our little guy's

606
00:49:36,483 --> 00:49:40,404
SPEAKER_00: all this equipment and there's all this beeping.

607
00:49:40,464 --> 00:49:41,984
SPEAKER_00: It's like a TV show of a hospital.

608
00:49:43,944 --> 00:49:54,626
SPEAKER_00: And the really tough thing was I did know my way around an ICU a little bit because my father had been intubated in an ICU, dying of lung cancer.

609
00:49:55,266 --> 00:49:58,347
SPEAKER_00: And so, and our son actually has the same name as my father.

610
00:49:58,747 --> 00:50:05,448
SPEAKER_00: So I go through this hospital door and it says Joseph A. Vodich, which is the name of our son and the name of my father.

611
00:50:07,253 --> 00:50:10,135
SPEAKER_00: And on some level, the same thing's going on.

612
00:50:10,155 --> 00:50:15,418
SPEAKER_00: I mean, they're both fighting for their lives with a, you know, they can't breathe and they're intubated.

613
00:50:17,079 --> 00:50:19,220
SPEAKER_00: And of course, with my father, that was the end of the road.

614
00:50:20,240 --> 00:50:24,923
SPEAKER_00: And Chasten was really, my husband was really good about reminding me that like, that's not what's happening here.

615
00:50:25,183 --> 00:50:27,945
SPEAKER_00: It doesn't have to be.

616
00:50:28,785 --> 00:50:32,627
SPEAKER_00: And he had been a CNA too, so he kind of knew his way around the hospital too, which helped.

617
00:50:35,163 --> 00:50:38,425
SPEAKER_00: didn't help as much as his emotional intelligence helped, but you know, all of that.

618
00:50:41,467 --> 00:50:43,868
SPEAKER_00: And it's weird too, cause you know, he's sedated, right?

619
00:50:43,948 --> 00:50:51,553
SPEAKER_00: Cause you do that, you know, when a patient is intubated, but he's still kind of like there.

620
00:50:51,753 --> 00:50:59,037
SPEAKER_00: I mean, I remember if I held his hand, you know, his tiny little fingers would like wrap around my pinky finger and

621
00:51:01,334 --> 00:51:04,196
SPEAKER_00: just the utter powerlessness of not knowing what was gonna happen next.

622
00:51:04,216 --> 00:51:12,961
SPEAKER_00: Because you want your doctor to be able to say like, okay, this is what's going on, and this is what'll happen the next few days, and you can expect this, and that'll happen.

623
00:51:13,581 --> 00:51:18,344
SPEAKER_00: And instead, we're asked, there's only one question we really care about, of course, which is like, is he getting better?

624
00:51:18,824 --> 00:51:20,085
SPEAKER_00: How will we know when he's getting better?

625
00:51:20,405 --> 00:51:24,868
SPEAKER_00: And basically what they told us was, you'll know he's getting better when he stops getting worse.

626
00:51:26,518 --> 00:51:30,662
SPEAKER_00: And just to see how tiny he was, like fighting for his life.

627
00:51:32,543 --> 00:51:41,071
SPEAKER_00: And you're just waiting, you're just watching these numbers, the O2 number and the pulse, and you're just waiting for days.

628
00:51:43,053 --> 00:51:45,755
SPEAKER_00: And going back and forth to the cafeteria,

629
00:51:47,555 --> 00:51:51,076
SPEAKER_00: Like I said, I was on leave, but that was when there was that supply chain crisis.

630
00:51:52,056 --> 00:51:55,537
SPEAKER_00: And there were ships backed up in the ports of LA and Long Beach.

631
00:51:55,557 --> 00:52:01,379
SPEAKER_00: And there were certain things that I just, you know, even then, obviously I had to take care of or be on the phone to deal with.

632
00:52:01,899 --> 00:52:08,321
SPEAKER_00: I remember one time I had to get on a Zoom so quickly that there wasn't time to leave the hospital room he was in.

633
00:52:08,361 --> 00:52:15,143
SPEAKER_00: So I went into the bathroom and shut the door behind me of the little ICU room so I could put on a virtual background so that people weren't distracted by it.

634
00:52:16,043 --> 00:52:17,023
SPEAKER_00: seeing that I was in a hospital.

635
00:52:17,804 --> 00:52:25,506
SPEAKER_00: And then there were these weird kind of ugly politics of like attacking the idea that we were in on even taking parental leave in the first place.

636
00:52:27,247 --> 00:52:34,969
SPEAKER_00: And then just, I don't know, just the image I can't get out of my mind is how tiny he was in this bed, which is for a kid.

637
00:52:34,989 --> 00:52:37,910
SPEAKER_00: I mean, this is a pediatric ICU, but he still looks so tiny.

638
00:52:38,370 --> 00:52:42,211
SPEAKER_00: And then all this gear like coming out, coming out of his throat and

639
00:52:45,517 --> 00:52:55,504
SPEAKER_01: Did you appreciate how transparent and forward and honest the doctors were in telling you that they don't know and that we'll only know once he stops getting worse?

640
00:52:56,145 --> 00:52:56,805
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I guess.

641
00:52:56,825 --> 00:52:59,587
SPEAKER_00: I mean, of course, the thing you want the doctor to tell you is the answer.

642
00:52:59,907 --> 00:53:01,529
SPEAKER_00: You want the doctor to tell you what's going to happen.

643
00:53:02,749 --> 00:53:04,531
SPEAKER_00: But if they can't, then they shouldn't.

644
00:53:04,611 --> 00:53:08,013
SPEAKER_00: And we did have really great doctors and nurses.

645
00:53:08,474 --> 00:53:10,375
SPEAKER_00: Does anyone stand out in your mind during that journey?

646
00:53:11,761 --> 00:53:22,268
SPEAKER_00: I remember a doctor had just the right kind of bedside manner of being really honest to the point of being blunt, but obviously acknowledging our feelings.

647
00:53:22,348 --> 00:53:26,211
SPEAKER_00: And we were saying, I think we were asking some question.

648
00:53:26,231 --> 00:53:29,453
SPEAKER_00: I don't know exactly what we were asking, but I think he knew the real question was how bad is this?

649
00:53:30,434 --> 00:53:33,216
SPEAKER_00: And just saying, you're in a critical care unit.

650
00:53:33,856 --> 00:53:36,097
SPEAKER_00: So that's how serious this is.

651
00:53:36,978 --> 00:53:40,260
SPEAKER_00: And then walking us through kind of what we were up against and what might happen.

652
00:53:43,342 --> 00:53:46,744
SPEAKER_00: And nurses, I mean, they were all great.

653
00:53:47,505 --> 00:53:51,427
SPEAKER_00: Really gave me even deeper appreciation for nurses than I already have.

654
00:53:52,468 --> 00:53:56,010
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, the biggest thing was just telling us the truth, doing what they could.

655
00:53:57,779 --> 00:54:11,902
SPEAKER_00: I think also being pretty tolerant, it must be difficult to do your job as a doctor when every, especially a pediatric doctor in an ICU where every room you go, there's like parents hanging on your every word, right?

656
00:54:13,242 --> 00:54:14,623
SPEAKER_00: Probably hovering around you on rounds.

657
00:54:14,643 --> 00:54:17,263
SPEAKER_00: I know we were just trying to figure out like, what does this mean?

658
00:54:20,504 --> 00:54:21,044
SPEAKER_00: But we got through it.

659
00:54:23,785 --> 00:54:25,705
SPEAKER_00: One day he was better than the day before.

660
00:54:27,254 --> 00:54:33,016
SPEAKER_00: And I remember just after those nights every day thinking like, I'm just getting used to the idea of even being a parent.

661
00:54:33,176 --> 00:54:38,678
SPEAKER_00: And could it really be that just a few weeks in, like that's all the time we're gonna have with him?

662
00:54:39,038 --> 00:54:41,639
SPEAKER_00: Like, how could that be?

663
00:54:44,240 --> 00:54:47,401
SPEAKER_00: But then one day he was a little bit better and the next day he was a little bit stronger.

664
00:54:47,461 --> 00:54:50,542
SPEAKER_00: And one day the tube comes out and,

665
00:54:52,495 --> 00:54:58,946
SPEAKER_00: I have this picture of him just looking up at me when after we got, they got the tube out and he's even off the oxygen.

666
00:54:58,966 --> 00:55:03,154
SPEAKER_00: I think he's just looking up at me and just being a baby again.

667
00:55:04,687 --> 00:55:05,547
SPEAKER_01: to just be a dad again.

668
00:55:05,967 --> 00:55:06,108
SPEAKER_00: And.

669
00:55:06,388 --> 00:55:22,433
SPEAKER_01: Do you ever enter that mental space again, where you start feeling those emotions that you felt that day in the ICU, where you're worried about perhaps something you don't need to be worried about, but because you were in that position not so long ago, that it still stirs up those emotions.

670
00:55:22,981 --> 00:55:23,622
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, maybe.

671
00:55:23,682 --> 00:55:39,114
SPEAKER_00: I mean, I don't want to self-psychoanalyze, but I think because I had a very intense job kind of waiting for me, when I wasn't dealing with that, there was something else that was equally demanding that I could kind of put my mind toward for better and for worse in terms of my own health.

672
00:55:42,216 --> 00:55:48,902
SPEAKER_00: But yeah, I think on some level that's still, but I want to describe it as like a,

673
00:55:50,477 --> 00:55:58,920
SPEAKER_00: It's also, I think, an amazing thing to just know, you know, with him and his sister, because I know what they were up against at one point in their lives.

674
00:55:59,360 --> 00:56:05,042
SPEAKER_00: Like this morning, before I went to the airport, it was probably 4.30 in the morning, and he's a morning person somehow.

675
00:56:06,087 --> 00:56:15,649
SPEAKER_00: he's four years old now, just like detects, you know, I'm like tiptoeing out, trying not to wake the dog, trying not to wake Chasten, like gingerly trying to like carry my suitcase downstairs.

676
00:56:15,669 --> 00:56:20,890
SPEAKER_00: And of course he like activates, finds me, runs up, like jumps up in his little pajamas.

677
00:56:20,970 --> 00:56:22,910
SPEAKER_00: And like, he's like 45 pounds.

678
00:56:22,970 --> 00:56:33,572
SPEAKER_00: And of course in the back of my head, as I'm having these normal interactions with my like healthy, big kids, you know, just realizing how close he came when he was, you know, a few pounds.

679
00:56:35,494 --> 00:56:39,578
SPEAKER_00: Our daughter too, she had some feeding issues when she was first born.

680
00:56:39,618 --> 00:56:41,280
SPEAKER_00: And so we had to fight.

681
00:56:42,321 --> 00:56:47,506
SPEAKER_00: The doctors would come in, during the first few days, we had to stay in the hospital after they'd been born.

682
00:56:47,526 --> 00:56:52,291
SPEAKER_00: We got to, I don't want to take you through our entire story, but it was what they call a surprise adoption.

683
00:56:52,311 --> 00:56:52,891
SPEAKER_00: So we got a call.

684
00:56:53,552 --> 00:56:55,133
SPEAKER_00: And the next day we're at the hospital.

685
00:56:56,453 --> 00:56:57,894
SPEAKER_00: And- Life moves quickly.

686
00:56:58,094 --> 00:56:59,014
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, very quickly.

687
00:56:59,054 --> 00:57:00,755
SPEAKER_00: Especially like, oh, by the way, it's twins.

688
00:57:00,795 --> 00:57:05,836
SPEAKER_00: Like we'd been on a list for a long time hoping to adopt, but they said, no, it's twins.

689
00:57:05,857 --> 00:57:06,617
SPEAKER_00: Here's the situation.

690
00:57:06,677 --> 00:57:07,197
SPEAKER_00: Can you come?

691
00:57:07,357 --> 00:57:08,017
SPEAKER_00: And then we were there.

692
00:57:09,238 --> 00:57:15,400
SPEAKER_00: But then we couldn't leave the hospital for several days because they were born early and they wanted to make sure they were okay.

693
00:57:16,137 --> 00:57:21,098
SPEAKER_00: And with her, she just had trouble feeding early on, so they put a little tube.

694
00:57:21,778 --> 00:57:22,079
SPEAKER_00: What is it?

695
00:57:22,279 --> 00:57:24,919
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah, NG, they called it.

696
00:57:26,600 --> 00:57:31,421
SPEAKER_00: And then we got her on the bottle, and they're telling you, like, you have to do like 25 milliliters or whatever.

697
00:57:31,441 --> 00:57:32,901
SPEAKER_00: It was like down to the milliliter.

698
00:57:33,241 --> 00:57:34,382
SPEAKER_00: And we'd be like fighting for it.

699
00:57:34,402 --> 00:57:34,782
SPEAKER_00: We'd be like.

700
00:57:35,042 --> 00:57:36,962
SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I guess, yeah.

701
00:57:37,463 --> 00:57:43,224
SPEAKER_01: That's why we discourage giving water to newborns, because there's no room, and you gotta give them nutrition, so.

702
00:57:43,624 --> 00:57:48,386
SPEAKER_00: And I did not grow up around infants, so I'm figuring out the whole bottle feeding thing to begin with.

703
00:57:49,306 --> 00:57:51,707
SPEAKER_00: And we're writing it on this whiteboard.

704
00:57:51,907 --> 00:57:56,029
SPEAKER_00: When it's 23 versus 25, like two milliliters difference, we would notice, right?

705
00:57:56,069 --> 00:58:02,011
SPEAKER_00: And I'm thinking about that now when she's just demolishing chicken nuggets or whatever.

706
00:58:02,031 --> 00:58:04,972
SPEAKER_00: You know what it took to get you- Yeah, to enjoy these chicken nuggets.

707
00:58:04,992 --> 00:58:06,513
SPEAKER_00: I don't even know how I got onto that, sorry.

708
00:58:07,073 --> 00:58:07,914
SPEAKER_01: That's a great story.

709
00:58:12,036 --> 00:58:22,463
SPEAKER_01: I didn't mean it in terms of a pathological statement that you're experiencing PTSD, but it's natural, not pathological, to remember those emotions.

710
00:58:23,103 --> 00:58:30,588
SPEAKER_01: And humans reprocess traumas and griefs and scary moments like that as part of our natural cycle in order to help deal with them better.

711
00:58:31,228 --> 00:58:36,810
SPEAKER_01: So in fact, that would be a healthy non-pathological thing to experience.

712
00:58:38,410 --> 00:58:50,734
SPEAKER_01: You had a lot of things going in your favor during this moment that a lot of my patients, I work in a community health center, in our CHCs that we see for our patients, that they have barriers to access.

713
00:58:51,794 --> 00:58:54,455
SPEAKER_01: So parental leave, great that you had that.

714
00:58:55,075 --> 00:59:02,620
SPEAKER_01: A compassionate partner, an advocate, someone to be there with you is such an invaluable tool to have.

715
00:59:04,241 --> 00:59:08,383
SPEAKER_01: Insurance that actually covers, that doesn't create barriers.

716
00:59:09,784 --> 00:59:11,385
SPEAKER_01: But so many Americans don't have that.

717
00:59:13,166 --> 00:59:15,267
SPEAKER_01: Why is our healthcare system so broken?

718
00:59:15,527 --> 00:59:17,588
SPEAKER_01: Was this talked about at cabinet meetings?

719
00:59:18,389 --> 00:59:20,010
SPEAKER_01: How do you feel about it in general today?

720
00:59:20,345 --> 00:59:27,254
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean, when I ran for president, which was before any of this, before your parents, before we knew our way around a children's hospital,

721
00:59:29,848 --> 00:59:41,996
SPEAKER_00: I believed then and I believe now that we need to overhaul the system, especially in terms of insurance, that everybody should have access to that level of insurance and that we can do that through a plan that anybody can get it on a public plan.

722
00:59:42,316 --> 00:59:48,561
SPEAKER_00: If you want a private plan, fine, but we provide a quality public plan like Medicare, better than Medicare, but in that same way.

723
00:59:50,422 --> 00:59:58,267
SPEAKER_00: And everybody should have that because, yeah, I mean, we had so much going for us, including just the good health insurance that came with my job.

724
00:59:59,526 --> 01:00:07,469
SPEAKER_00: And if we didn't have that, or if I didn't have Chasten and extended family around, like you said, paid leave.

725
01:00:07,629 --> 01:00:10,390
SPEAKER_00: I mean, just being able to actually take the time to be there for them.

726
01:00:10,590 --> 01:00:11,370
SPEAKER_00: I don't know who else would have.

727
01:00:11,390 --> 01:00:14,671
SPEAKER_00: I mean, when one of us was with him, the other one had to be with our daughter.

728
01:00:15,191 --> 01:00:34,218
SPEAKER_00: I remember being in, we got a hotel kind of across the road and being in the room with my daughter, making phone calls to members of Congress late in the night, trying to sell the infrastructure bill, because we were in the middle of that process too, knowing that Gus and Chasten were down at the ICU and she's perking up every couple hours wanting to be fed.

729
01:00:34,458 --> 01:00:40,280
SPEAKER_00: And how are you supposed to deal with any of that if you can't get time off work?

730
01:00:41,441 --> 01:00:55,955
SPEAKER_00: if you don't have the gas money to get back and forth to where you need to be, if you don't have the kind of family network that we relied on, in-laws, friends, and a lot of that is addressable.

731
01:00:56,095 --> 01:01:03,943
SPEAKER_00: I mean, obviously you can't expect the government to be responsible for what your family looks like, but of course, everybody in this country should have

732
01:01:04,964 --> 01:01:08,606
SPEAKER_00: access to that insurance, should have that insurance automatically.

733
01:01:09,006 --> 01:01:16,670
SPEAKER_01: Do you think your healthcare vision when you ran for president would be different had you have been a father beforehand?

734
01:01:18,631 --> 01:01:20,392
SPEAKER_00: Well, definitely be even more passionate about it.

735
01:01:21,433 --> 01:01:24,094
SPEAKER_00: I think in terms of things I've learned along the way,

736
01:01:27,480 --> 01:01:41,411
SPEAKER_00: more appreciation for the role of nurses as well as doctors, more appreciation for the things that surround the healthcare experience, like transportation, stuff that's not in the doctor's office or in the hospital.

737
01:01:41,451 --> 01:01:42,912
SPEAKER_00: People don't associate with healthcare.

738
01:01:42,932 --> 01:01:43,553
SPEAKER_00: Right, yeah.

739
01:01:44,033 --> 01:01:46,855
SPEAKER_00: But of course, like just getting back and forth to the hospital, you know, that kind of thing.

740
01:01:48,817 --> 01:01:51,679
SPEAKER_00: And then through a different set of experiences, realizing,

741
01:01:53,645 --> 01:02:02,609
SPEAKER_00: more than I appreciated several years ago, when the conversation was all about Medicare, Medicare for all, my plan was called Medicare for all who want it, but like get everybody to something like Medicare.

742
01:02:03,530 --> 01:02:08,352
SPEAKER_00: I have more appreciations for the issues and problems around Medicare now too, because of what my mom's going through.

743
01:02:08,452 --> 01:02:15,015
SPEAKER_00: So while we've got little ones and we're taking care of them, my mom broke her hip last year in a fall.

744
01:02:16,836 --> 01:02:24,247
SPEAKER_00: During the course of that, we learned some things while she was in the hospital on the cognitive side that she's facing.

745
01:02:26,830 --> 01:02:32,458
SPEAKER_00: And at one point I was trying to get her medication sorted out and realized that she didn't have insurance anymore because

746
01:02:33,680 --> 01:02:43,050
SPEAKER_00: Basically, I'm simplifying, but not that much, basically because she didn't answer an email and some mail that went to an old address that she didn't even have anymore.

747
01:02:43,170 --> 01:02:45,933
SPEAKER_00: And she got dropped for a while on her prescription insurance.

748
01:02:47,175 --> 01:02:51,119
SPEAKER_00: And how was the system expecting somebody who's on Medicare

749
01:02:53,286 --> 01:03:02,416
SPEAKER_00: But somebody who has dementia is expected to deal with this bureaucratic stuff that I find confounding.

750
01:03:02,476 --> 01:03:04,918
SPEAKER_01: As a doctor, I found it confusing.

751
01:03:05,099 --> 01:03:12,647
SPEAKER_01: I had the administrator for CMS, Chiquita Brooks-LaSure, she was struggling doing this for her parents.

752
01:03:12,927 --> 01:03:14,470
SPEAKER_01: and she ran the whole system.

753
01:03:14,490 --> 01:03:15,692
SPEAKER_01: And she's in charge of the whole thing, yeah.

754
01:03:15,832 --> 01:03:22,241
SPEAKER_00: So I do think this is really important because there are all these policy fights over how to get everybody something like Medicare, which I believe in and I care about.

755
01:03:22,982 --> 01:03:24,545
SPEAKER_00: But sometimes we talk only about that.

756
01:03:24,565 --> 01:03:26,287
SPEAKER_00: It makes it sound like, well, Medicare is just fine.

757
01:03:26,588 --> 01:03:27,950
SPEAKER_00: Everything there is working just fine.

758
01:03:28,797 --> 01:03:36,661
SPEAKER_00: And the reality is this, and these layers of the Medicare Advantage plans, figuring out what she was covered for when she needed intensive inpatient rehab.

759
01:03:36,681 --> 01:03:38,301
SPEAKER_00: Right, the different alphabet of it all.

760
01:03:38,622 --> 01:03:38,882
SPEAKER_00: Yes.

761
01:03:40,783 --> 01:03:50,607
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, like I remember news stories right here, or even my own policy plans talking about Part D versus Part B or whatever, but I don't really know how many letters up it went until I was trying to navigate her stuff.

762
01:03:50,627 --> 01:03:52,368
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, there's a lot of letters, yeah.

763
01:03:53,088 --> 01:04:00,034
SPEAKER_00: Anyway, so that's something else that I think I learned about through experience that's kind of feeding back into how I think about healthcare.

764
01:04:00,574 --> 01:04:03,917
SPEAKER_01: Yeah, for me, the big issues surround

765
01:04:05,808 --> 01:04:14,953
SPEAKER_01: horizontal and now vertical consolidation that I see happening in a way that I feel like in any other industry would be hyper-regulated, but in healthcare it's not.

766
01:04:15,813 --> 01:04:25,398
SPEAKER_01: And not only is that not good because healthcare is important, it's probably the industry where it's least acceptable to have a monopoly.

767
01:04:26,378 --> 01:04:29,979
SPEAKER_01: Like if a toy company has a monopoly, who cares?

768
01:04:30,660 --> 01:04:32,140
SPEAKER_01: A luggage company has a monopoly.

769
01:04:32,940 --> 01:04:44,784
SPEAKER_01: But when it's a healthcare company, like this Uberization of healthcare, where you're deciding people's health over profits or under profits is really problematic.

770
01:04:45,805 --> 01:04:48,966
SPEAKER_01: And I don't know why it's not a topic.

771
01:04:49,246 --> 01:04:52,447
SPEAKER_01: It feels like it should be a bipartisan topic that everyone is discussing.

772
01:04:53,738 --> 01:04:57,359
SPEAKER_01: where I don't hear of any great solutions being proposed.

773
01:04:57,479 --> 01:05:00,000
SPEAKER_01: Have you heard of anything that makes sense?

774
01:05:00,340 --> 01:05:01,380
SPEAKER_01: Because I have some ideas.

775
01:05:02,000 --> 01:05:03,881
SPEAKER_01: I'd love to hear more about them.

776
01:05:03,981 --> 01:05:10,303
SPEAKER_01: So as an example, for me, what frustrates me so often is being a primary care doctor, I want to get ahead of problems.

777
01:05:11,023 --> 01:05:17,645
SPEAKER_01: It's much more cost effective and health effective to prevent a heart attack than it is to treat one when it's happening.

778
01:05:18,041 --> 01:05:23,709
SPEAKER_01: We obviously need to create cures and treatments when people are already sick, but it's great to get ahead.

779
01:05:24,730 --> 01:05:25,792
SPEAKER_01: We don't invest in that.

780
01:05:25,892 --> 01:05:32,261
SPEAKER_01: And a big reason why insurance companies don't support that is because a lot of our insurers are driven by employment.

781
01:05:33,117 --> 01:05:34,838
SPEAKER_01: And that employment changes quite often.

782
01:05:34,858 --> 01:05:40,141
SPEAKER_01: It's not like how it used to be 50 years ago, where people stayed with the same industry or the same employer for ages.

783
01:05:41,022 --> 01:05:46,145
SPEAKER_01: So they have no incentive to keep that person as healthy as possible.

784
01:05:46,165 --> 01:05:49,647
SPEAKER_01: They want to spend as small amount as possible.

785
01:05:51,015 --> 01:06:08,049
SPEAKER_01: So finding some sort of way where if a person begins with an insurer, they now stay with that insurer for a period of time, even if they switch employers would be valuable because now the incentive changes to keep that person healthy because that incentive is also tied to your profit.

786
01:06:08,549 --> 01:06:19,698
SPEAKER_01: Second, a big issue comes for me with prior authorizations and insurers deciding care for our patients, as opposed to doctors deciding care for patients.

787
01:06:21,227 --> 01:06:28,635
SPEAKER_01: And I see where there are true issues with this because the insurance companies have a fiduciary responsibility to their shareholders, not to patients.

788
01:06:29,395 --> 01:06:30,957
SPEAKER_01: That sounds terrible, but that's the reality.

789
01:06:31,597 --> 01:06:38,584
SPEAKER_01: Doctors have a responsibility to patients, but inherently as individuals, they also have some economic responsibility to themselves.

790
01:06:39,513 --> 01:06:51,562
SPEAKER_01: So the insurers are put in this position where they have to mitigate how much spend is happening, whether it's appropriate, whether these treatments make sense, are they standard of care, they need to curtail spending when there's waste or fraud.

791
01:06:54,187 --> 01:06:58,349
SPEAKER_01: Whenever either party makes a decision, there is the possibility for bias to occur.

792
01:06:59,349 --> 01:07:21,660
SPEAKER_01: Why isn't there a middle objective group, a court, a referee, if you will, to help make that decision as opposed to creating arguments from two parties that vehemently disagree and partly driven by their own biases, whether it's for their own wallets, for their patients, for their companies or shareholders.

793
01:07:22,220 --> 01:07:23,241
SPEAKER_01: So I think that would be great.

794
01:07:23,821 --> 01:07:24,962
SPEAKER_01: I haven't heard that discussed.

795
01:07:25,442 --> 01:07:29,705
SPEAKER_01: And the obvious one that I think is discussed is the transparency aspect of it.

796
01:07:30,405 --> 01:07:41,552
SPEAKER_01: Where if you look at an industry in healthcare, like cosmetic surgery, for example, where you can call an office, find out how much a nose job costs, you can decide as a consumer where you want to go.

797
01:07:42,232 --> 01:07:47,676
SPEAKER_01: But when it comes to a patient coming to see me and I tell them that, hey, they need an MRI or they need a surgery,

798
01:07:48,804 --> 01:07:51,547
SPEAKER_01: For them to find out how much that costs, boy, is that a process.

799
01:07:51,587 --> 01:07:55,390
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and it costs something else depending who you're insuring.

800
01:07:55,410 --> 01:07:57,672
SPEAKER_00: It feels like it costs something different depending what day of the week it is.

801
01:07:57,712 --> 01:07:58,753
SPEAKER_00: It's very hard to understand.

802
01:07:58,813 --> 01:08:04,478
SPEAKER_01: It's honestly, sadly true because it's in-network today, out-of-network tomorrow.

803
01:08:05,318 --> 01:08:15,768
SPEAKER_01: This doctor is now dropped by this insurer, and it expired, and the disastrous implications of that mean people go bankrupt in our country as a result of...

804
01:08:16,517 --> 01:08:18,798
SPEAKER_01: actually at times doing the right things.

805
01:08:19,698 --> 01:08:20,699
SPEAKER_01: I did a live tour.

806
01:08:21,819 --> 01:08:25,021
SPEAKER_01: It was kind of a comedy show to get people excited about healthcare.

807
01:08:25,581 --> 01:08:34,325
SPEAKER_01: And we ended the show by telling a story of a teacher who was insured, great shape, exercised regularly, ran marathons, I believe, right?

808
01:08:35,225 --> 01:08:38,288
SPEAKER_01: and had a heart attack, unplanned incident, right?

809
01:08:38,328 --> 01:08:40,711
SPEAKER_01: Can't prepare for a heart attack, unlucky situation.

810
01:08:41,131 --> 01:08:44,334
SPEAKER_01: Was taken to a hospital that was the closest because it was an emergency.

811
01:08:44,995 --> 01:08:53,423
SPEAKER_01: Turns out that that hospital or the provider was out of network, got hit with a surprise quarter million dollar bill or some huge money.

812
01:08:54,023 --> 01:08:55,765
SPEAKER_01: where it has nothing to do with him.

813
01:08:55,825 --> 01:08:57,146
SPEAKER_01: He's doing all the right things.

814
01:08:57,286 --> 01:08:59,508
SPEAKER_01: It's an emergent situation, how that happens.

815
01:09:00,169 --> 01:09:09,257
SPEAKER_01: And the only reason that that situation was solved was because he went to media and the pressure for media on this institution solved this issue.

816
01:09:10,474 --> 01:09:20,120
SPEAKER_01: So in this day and age, the fact that that's still happening in addition to the hybrid complex administrative heavy system that we function in, I'm confused.

817
01:09:20,740 --> 01:09:22,541
SPEAKER_01: So I'm curious what your thoughts are.

818
01:09:22,621 --> 01:09:29,386
SPEAKER_00: I mean, one ingredient in each one of those stories that I think doesn't get talked about enough is power.

819
01:09:29,406 --> 01:09:31,287
SPEAKER_00: So the insurance company has a certain amount of power.

820
01:09:31,867 --> 01:09:35,831
SPEAKER_00: and sometimes maybe more power than the doctor trying to get something done.

821
01:09:36,191 --> 01:09:44,339
SPEAKER_00: The patient in the situation you're describing, obviously you have no power if you're just literally being rushed to the hospital with a heart attack.

822
01:09:44,379 --> 01:09:46,120
SPEAKER_00: And then once you're being seen,

823
01:09:47,101 --> 01:09:51,104
SPEAKER_00: do you have any power as a patient to guide the outcomes that make sense for you?

824
01:09:51,845 --> 01:09:58,530
SPEAKER_00: Or is it all kind of sitting with these for-profit entities that are sometimes dealing among themselves, right?

825
01:09:58,550 --> 01:10:04,175
SPEAKER_00: Sometimes, as you know, the hospital and the insurer who are supposed to be in that adversarial process are actually part of the same company.

826
01:10:04,935 --> 01:10:07,137
SPEAKER_00: That's the integration, which is nuts.

827
01:10:08,218 --> 01:10:12,221
SPEAKER_00: And yeah, you think about if you're not lucky enough to

828
01:10:15,050 --> 01:10:16,151
SPEAKER_00: Have your story covered?

829
01:10:16,171 --> 01:10:20,292
SPEAKER_00: I mean, how many people have been in that same boat and just gone bankrupt because of it, right?

830
01:10:20,712 --> 01:10:22,353
SPEAKER_00: Or gotten worse patient care because of it.

831
01:10:23,093 --> 01:10:26,955
SPEAKER_01: And you can't expect- Or spent their hard-earned savings on it.

832
01:10:27,655 --> 01:10:34,657
SPEAKER_01: Because while we talk about instances where people can't afford it and go bankrupt, some people lose their entire life savings over it.

833
01:10:35,198 --> 01:10:36,838
SPEAKER_01: And that's not a bankruptcy issue.

834
01:10:36,858 --> 01:10:41,500
SPEAKER_01: Now you're just sitting at zero and have to work into an age where it's not sustainable.

835
01:10:41,805 --> 01:10:46,326
SPEAKER_00: But this, again, is why I think we really need to have a public plan that everybody can get on.

836
01:10:46,426 --> 01:10:51,687
SPEAKER_00: And then if a private plan wants to stay in business, they have to show that they're even better.

837
01:10:52,628 --> 01:10:56,668
SPEAKER_00: And there is a race to the top instead of a race to the bottom.

838
01:10:57,809 --> 01:11:04,170
SPEAKER_00: I think that what we've seen right now, I mean, look at the fact that Medicare is not even allowed except in limited cases.

839
01:11:04,530 --> 01:11:08,951
SPEAKER_00: We tried to change this in the last administration, but only in limited cases can they even negotiate drug prices, right?

840
01:11:09,011 --> 01:11:11,652
SPEAKER_00: Even though the overwhelming majority of Americans think we ought to do this.

841
01:11:12,632 --> 01:11:20,137
SPEAKER_00: This shows that there's also a level of power, not just the power equations that happen kind of in a patient care situation, but obviously in Washington, right?

842
01:11:20,537 --> 01:11:25,239
SPEAKER_00: To stop that from happening more when people expect it and demand it.

843
01:11:25,640 --> 01:11:27,781
SPEAKER_00: So you have to have something that's accountable to the public.

844
01:11:28,221 --> 01:11:40,388
SPEAKER_00: And right now, from the top on down in Washington, I think there's a culture of very little accountability that seeps its way down into how decisions are made and those entities that are part of the public sector.

845
01:11:41,288 --> 01:11:57,997
SPEAKER_00: Then not being willing to use I mean again, I know it's a very different sector But to take the example I would share from the airlines where we realized we had a certain amount of power because the law placed it in our hands To look over the shoulders of these corporations and make sure that they were treating people fairly

846
01:12:00,442 --> 01:12:01,643
SPEAKER_00: That's true in the airline sector.

847
01:12:02,103 --> 01:12:16,672
SPEAKER_00: It's also true in the health sector that if the right people are using the tools that are already there, and we should give them more tools, then a patient knows somebody's fighting for them when they're fighting an insurance company or when they're fighting to get their bills lowered.

848
01:12:17,813 --> 01:12:22,936
SPEAKER_00: Because when you're in that situation, of course, the last thing you should be thinking about is insurance or money at all.

849
01:12:24,477 --> 01:12:36,044
SPEAKER_00: And just the fact that when you go in to get treated, right, as a patient in America, the first question you get asked as you're conscious is about your insurance, shows you how out of whack our priorities have been as a country.

850
01:12:37,365 --> 01:12:43,569
SPEAKER_01: What drives me up a wall in this scenario is politicians struggle with this themselves with their own family members.

851
01:12:44,409 --> 01:12:48,352
SPEAKER_01: When they break a hip, when they have a hospitalization for an unrelated issue,

852
01:12:49,302 --> 01:12:53,148
SPEAKER_01: If they're experiencing it, why don't they take steps to counteract this?

853
01:12:54,089 --> 01:13:02,261
SPEAKER_01: And right now, I mean, our current Secretary of Health and Human Services doesn't seem like he cares about making a change in this.

854
01:13:02,601 --> 01:13:04,724
SPEAKER_01: I mean, I love the slogan, Make America Healthy,

855
01:13:05,565 --> 01:13:06,886
SPEAKER_01: I don't know where the again comes from.

856
01:13:08,588 --> 01:13:16,414
SPEAKER_01: Again, what era are we going to where people live shorter lives, where bacteria and stubbing your toe was a death sentence?

857
01:13:16,514 --> 01:13:17,095
SPEAKER_01: I don't know.

858
01:13:17,115 --> 01:13:18,536
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean, that's the thing.

859
01:13:18,576 --> 01:13:21,979
SPEAKER_00: There's this imagined golden age when they seem to...

860
01:13:22,179 --> 01:13:25,942
SPEAKER_00: But I think the broader point is the Secretary of Health and Human Services doesn't have to worry about this.

861
01:13:26,943 --> 01:13:27,563
SPEAKER_00: It's not a problem.

862
01:13:27,984 --> 01:13:29,505
SPEAKER_00: He can hire somebody to worry about it for him.

863
01:13:30,145 --> 01:13:31,987
SPEAKER_00: And he works for somebody who's even richer than he is.

864
01:13:33,738 --> 01:13:47,172
SPEAKER_00: And you have this circle of folks making these decisions who, look, the president literally owns a club that you have to pay a million dollars just to get into.

865
01:13:49,424 --> 01:13:55,768
SPEAKER_00: These are not folks who have navigated the system in a way that they have to worry about any of this.

866
01:13:57,389 --> 01:14:04,093
SPEAKER_00: Every human being has health issues and is humbled at some level by that when you're encountering a doctor.

867
01:14:04,113 --> 01:14:18,283
SPEAKER_00: But even the hassles that somebody who has a good job and an upper middle-class income, let alone what you're up against if you're living in poverty or if you're a single mom of a medically fragile child or any of the scenarios that so many Americans are going through,

868
01:14:19,323 --> 01:14:20,084
SPEAKER_00: It's just not their problem.

869
01:14:22,445 --> 01:14:29,128
SPEAKER_01: Given that they're so unrelatable, as you describe, these million-dollar entry fees to clubs, why are they so popular?

870
01:14:30,208 --> 01:14:31,429
SPEAKER_00: Well, they're not, importantly, right?

871
01:14:31,529 --> 01:14:34,090
SPEAKER_00: I mean, they're very good at creating the impression that they're popular.

872
01:14:34,391 --> 01:14:35,371
SPEAKER_00: Interesting.

873
01:14:35,391 --> 01:14:36,091
SPEAKER_00: Tell me more about that.

874
01:14:36,111 --> 01:14:41,394
SPEAKER_00: Well, I mean, the big majority of the country disapproves of the way the president's doing business.

875
01:14:42,560 --> 01:14:43,421
SPEAKER_00: Big majority of the country.

876
01:14:44,062 --> 01:14:44,783
SPEAKER_00: Well, that's now.

877
01:14:45,163 --> 01:14:45,323
SPEAKER_00: Yeah.

878
01:14:45,584 --> 01:14:46,365
SPEAKER_00: But to get elected.

879
01:14:46,565 --> 01:14:46,765
SPEAKER_00: Yeah.

880
01:14:46,805 --> 01:14:48,928
SPEAKER_00: But even then, like, squeaked it out.

881
01:14:49,268 --> 01:14:55,836
SPEAKER_00: And, you know, if you ask, like, what share of the American people really identify as MAGA, it's less than a third.

882
01:14:56,537 --> 01:15:00,802
SPEAKER_00: Now, this brings me back to what I was saying earlier about our kind of whole system, right, that in our country,

883
01:15:01,982 --> 01:15:15,345
SPEAKER_00: a movement that's a minority like that, as long as they take over one of the two parties, and as long as you always have to choose between one of the two parties, and it's 51-49, then all you really need is to get slightly more than half of slightly more than half, right?

884
01:15:15,725 --> 01:15:17,766
SPEAKER_00: A party is half the country, you get half the party.

885
01:15:18,786 --> 01:15:19,586
SPEAKER_00: And you can run the table.

886
01:15:20,826 --> 01:15:27,008
SPEAKER_00: But I worry that there's this impression, because these people got elected, and unlike them, I do not deny that they got elected.

887
01:15:27,608 --> 01:15:29,088
SPEAKER_00: They got elected, they won an election.

888
01:15:30,249 --> 01:15:35,953
SPEAKER_00: But because they did that, for all kinds of overlapping and complicated reasons, that all this stuff they're doing is popular.

889
01:15:36,013 --> 01:15:36,493
SPEAKER_00: And it's not.

890
01:15:36,674 --> 01:15:48,262
SPEAKER_00: A strong majority of Americans believe that the government needs to be doing more, not less, to get people insured, including a public plan, whether you call it, you know, again, the version I called was Medicare for all who want it, because I think you should have a choice, but it was that or Medicare for all.

891
01:15:48,302 --> 01:15:49,603
SPEAKER_00: Strong majority of Americans believe in that.

892
01:15:50,363 --> 01:15:53,767
SPEAKER_00: Even stronger majority of Americans believe Medicare should at least be negotiating drug prices.

893
01:15:54,367 --> 01:16:02,216
SPEAKER_00: Strong majority of Americans think there needs to be more transparency in the way that medical services are priced.

894
01:16:03,257 --> 01:16:11,065
SPEAKER_00: Huge majority of Americans get that you should listen to your doctor on something like getting immunization for your child or for yourself.

895
01:16:12,059 --> 01:16:16,021
SPEAKER_00: that you should have that conversation and that there's a huge body of evidence around this.

896
01:16:16,061 --> 01:16:22,965
SPEAKER_00: One of the reasons why compared to a generation or two or three ago, people aren't dying of the same preventable communicable diseases at the same rates, right?

897
01:16:23,365 --> 01:16:25,006
SPEAKER_00: So don't get me wrong.

898
01:16:25,206 --> 01:16:28,928
SPEAKER_00: Like this is obviously a movement that was powerful enough to take over the government.

899
01:16:30,442 --> 01:16:49,931
SPEAKER_00: But I worry they create this illusion of invincibility and this illusion of inevitability that we really need to, I'm not just saying this in a partisan way, I'm just saying anybody who disagrees with some of what they're doing or all of what they're doing needs to recognize you're more powerful than you think, precisely because people believe this.

900
01:16:50,752 --> 01:16:56,014
SPEAKER_00: I went into the district of one of these right-wing members of Congress who refuses to hold a town hall.

901
01:16:56,934 --> 01:16:58,035
SPEAKER_00: It was in Western Wisconsin.

902
01:16:59,513 --> 01:17:01,956
SPEAKER_00: And I just thought, you know, you won't have a town hall with your constituents.

903
01:17:02,116 --> 01:17:04,199
SPEAKER_00: I'll do it for you.

904
01:17:04,239 --> 01:17:05,401
SPEAKER_00: A thousand people come out.

905
01:17:06,883 --> 01:17:09,927
SPEAKER_00: And I don't know if his challenger will defeat him or not.

906
01:17:10,027 --> 01:17:10,588
SPEAKER_00: I think she might.

907
01:17:12,410 --> 01:17:15,835
SPEAKER_00: But regardless of the campaign side of things,

908
01:17:17,557 --> 01:17:33,890
SPEAKER_00: What I know is that he noticed that was happening, and a few days before that town hall, miraculously, was one of the few Republicans to vote with the Democrats on extending the tax credits that help you pay your health premium under the ACA.

909
01:17:34,370 --> 01:17:35,431
SPEAKER_00: And this is not a moderate guy.

910
01:17:35,451 --> 01:17:37,092
SPEAKER_00: This is not somebody who normally votes with Democrats.

911
01:17:38,013 --> 01:17:44,478
SPEAKER_00: I'm mentioning this to say that even outside of the context of an election, which is when you have the most power as a citizen,

912
01:17:45,398 --> 01:17:55,223
SPEAKER_00: There are things we can do to mobilize around certain issues that get the attention of the politicians we already have, flawed though they might be, that make it clear in a way they can't ignore.

913
01:17:56,003 --> 01:18:08,349
SPEAKER_00: The same way that despite it being a core commitment of the Republican Party, even when they've been in charge of all three branches of government, they've never actually kept their promise to get rid of the Affordable Care Act.

914
01:18:08,529 --> 01:18:09,009
SPEAKER_00: Why is that?

915
01:18:09,669 --> 01:18:13,431
SPEAKER_00: Because they know that enough Americans believe that's wrong.

916
01:18:14,254 --> 01:18:14,915
SPEAKER_00: And so they won't do it.

917
01:18:15,855 --> 01:18:19,759
SPEAKER_00: I think we need to remember that in a moment like this, when people feel so disempowered as citizens.

918
01:18:20,079 --> 01:18:25,825
SPEAKER_01: Yeah, you know, I think about social media as a tool, as a way to mobilize and get people's attention.

919
01:18:26,786 --> 01:18:34,533
SPEAKER_01: Given the fact that there's this new modern Democratic Party that's evolving on social media, what do you think that movement represents?

920
01:18:35,093 --> 01:18:38,957
SPEAKER_01: Are there ideals in this party that perhaps in 2020,

921
01:18:39,477 --> 01:19:01,157
SPEAKER_00: the coastal cities around elite circles are landing well for people but then for the average american household it feels a bit disconnected do you are there any issues like that i think the most important thing is to stay rooted in everyday life so that's what somebody whether they're in brooklyn or in northern michigan where i live or in south bend indiana where i grew up or anywhere else has in common

922
01:19:02,287 --> 01:19:18,750
SPEAKER_00: And that can be linked to some really serious, you might say partisan commitments that we have, things we believe in, you know, that the wealthy ought to pay more in taxes and that the Affordable Care Act ought to be expanded and not abolished, you know, specific controversial political things that we believe that most people agree with us on.

923
01:19:18,810 --> 01:19:22,331
SPEAKER_00: But what I'm saying is they matter because they cash out in your everyday life, right?

924
01:19:23,511 --> 01:19:26,892
SPEAKER_00: I do think sometimes politics gets treated as this kind of like game in itself.

925
01:19:26,972 --> 01:19:29,553
SPEAKER_00: It happens more when you're in the run-up to a big election.

926
01:19:30,573 --> 01:19:30,713
SPEAKER_00: But

927
01:19:32,538 --> 01:19:42,591
SPEAKER_00: I've got to think that what most people are looking for, certainly my experience in office, running for office, and right now where I'm neither, you know, most people are just saying, what does this mean for me?

928
01:19:42,691 --> 01:19:45,534
SPEAKER_00: Is my life going to be different, better or worse?

929
01:19:45,955 --> 01:19:47,717
SPEAKER_00: Because you're in charge instead of you.

930
01:19:48,537 --> 01:19:51,881
SPEAKER_00: And if my party can make it, keep it about that, then I think we'll win.

931
01:19:52,361 --> 01:19:56,625
SPEAKER_00: And if it doesn't sound or feel like we're about that, then I think it's gonna be really hard to win.

932
01:19:57,106 --> 01:20:01,350
SPEAKER_00: So you think the power of positivity is stronger than the power of anger?

933
01:20:02,511 --> 01:20:04,013
SPEAKER_00: I think it's relating the two.

934
01:20:04,053 --> 01:20:08,978
SPEAKER_00: So yeah, I think, look, being angry, I'm angry about a lot of things, but on its own, it's not a governing vision.

935
01:20:10,639 --> 01:20:11,921
SPEAKER_00: And if it's all you have,

936
01:20:12,959 --> 01:20:16,321
SPEAKER_00: then when you actually wind up in charge, you're not gonna have a lot of answers.

937
01:20:16,421 --> 01:20:18,362
SPEAKER_00: If all you have to say is get rid of these guys, they suck.

938
01:20:18,583 --> 01:20:21,284
SPEAKER_00: And by the way, they do, and we should get rid of them by voting them out.

939
01:20:21,865 --> 01:20:26,147
SPEAKER_00: But that doesn't mean, that's only part of the proposition.

940
01:20:26,167 --> 01:20:29,329
SPEAKER_01: Yeah, running on a referendum is not a complete package.

941
01:20:29,349 --> 01:20:31,291
SPEAKER_00: Look, it might be enough for 2026.

942
01:20:31,391 --> 01:20:41,057
SPEAKER_00: I mean, enough people might just be mad about the terrible decisions being made by the Trump administration and the terrible things being enabled by the Republicans in Congress that the Republicans will lose and the Democrats will win.

943
01:20:41,777 --> 01:20:47,601
SPEAKER_00: But it would be so much more powerful if it was backed by a vision that said, okay, it doesn't have to be this way.

944
01:20:47,901 --> 01:20:49,602
SPEAKER_00: And here's how your everyday life is different.

945
01:20:50,182 --> 01:20:59,648
SPEAKER_00: If we make sure the wealthy pay their fair share in taxes, then there are more dollars available to expand Medicaid so that fewer people are sick and more people can pay for their coverage.

946
01:21:00,208 --> 01:21:12,679
SPEAKER_00: If you're on the Affordable Care Act, we can restore those tax credits that help you pay your premiums so you didn't have to choose between a mortgage payment and a healthcare payment, which is a choice a lot of people faced and wound up dropping their health insurance.

947
01:21:13,459 --> 01:21:18,364
SPEAKER_00: We can connect these things up to how your life is going and say, here's what we would be doing differently and why.

948
01:21:19,104 --> 01:21:20,285
SPEAKER_00: That is so much more powerful.

949
01:21:20,365 --> 01:21:21,066
SPEAKER_00: I guess whenever...

950
01:21:22,015 --> 01:21:24,376
SPEAKER_00: I'm pointing out the things this administration is doing wrong.

951
01:21:25,396 --> 01:21:31,839
SPEAKER_00: I want to do it in the name of what we could have that is better, not just that they're wrong, but that we could have something different and better.

952
01:21:32,179 --> 01:21:36,961
SPEAKER_00: When they're doing something corrupt, I want to show what it would be like if we had more integrity.

953
01:21:37,381 --> 01:21:45,084
SPEAKER_00: When they're cutting taxes for the richest people in the country, I want to remind folks of what we could be doing together with those dollars if the tax code were more fair.

954
01:21:45,764 --> 01:21:50,286
SPEAKER_00: So it's the negative and the positive go together, but you can't just do the negative for its own sake.

955
01:21:50,567 --> 01:21:50,807
SPEAKER_01: Yeah.

956
01:21:51,427 --> 01:22:01,812
SPEAKER_01: Do you think the fact that in 24, we had an election where the Democrats didn't have a primary, do you think in general primaries hurt or help a candidate?

957
01:22:01,872 --> 01:22:11,237
SPEAKER_01: Because in some ways, how we began this conversation, we talked about discourse sharpening your skills and your ideas, but in some ways it can create openings for opponents to come in.

958
01:22:11,297 --> 01:22:12,638
SPEAKER_01: So I'm curious where you land on that.

959
01:22:13,839 --> 01:22:16,821
SPEAKER_00: Ultimately, I think it's better when you have more of that competition.

960
01:22:16,982 --> 01:22:20,985
SPEAKER_00: I mean, I think back to the 2020 race where again, obviously I didn't win, but.

961
01:22:22,446 --> 01:22:23,047
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, what's that like?

962
01:22:23,067 --> 01:22:24,268
SPEAKER_00: What is it like running for president?

963
01:22:24,288 --> 01:22:25,569
SPEAKER_00: I know we'll come back to that.

964
01:22:25,909 --> 01:22:29,372
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean, first of all, when I ran, there were 20 people at first running.

965
01:22:29,852 --> 01:22:39,674
SPEAKER_00: Not all of them made it to the final stages, the Iowa caucuses, where I won Iowa and then came in second in New Hampshire, and then I dropped out after Nevada and South Carolina.

966
01:22:39,834 --> 01:22:44,335
SPEAKER_00: But the first debate, I remember they had to break it up into two heats, because there were 20 of us.

967
01:22:44,415 --> 01:22:45,315
SPEAKER_00: They did 10 at a time.

968
01:22:45,975 --> 01:22:49,115
SPEAKER_00: And I think if I remember right, I think we did 10 debates that I was part of.

969
01:22:49,495 --> 01:22:51,136
SPEAKER_00: The field shrank as we went.

970
01:22:53,036 --> 01:22:57,697
SPEAKER_00: And I don't know how to put into words, even now, years later, reflecting back on it, what that experience was like.

971
01:22:58,597 --> 01:23:13,840
SPEAKER_00: But I will say, of course it makes you sharper to have to defend your ideas, to think about in a field of competitors, like where you agree and where you disagree, where you have the same idea but a different style, where you have the same style but a different policy, where you have the same policy but a different way to get it done.

972
01:23:16,340 --> 01:23:23,882
SPEAKER_00: And I think that process, especially when the party doesn't have a leader, a single leader, so like now,

973
01:23:25,037 --> 01:23:32,402
SPEAKER_00: is extremely important for making clear kind of what a party cares about, what it focuses on, the style as well as the substance.

974
01:23:34,704 --> 01:23:39,187
SPEAKER_00: And yeah, I think we would have been, we're always well served when there's more of a contest.

975
01:23:39,207 --> 01:23:39,387
SPEAKER_00: Yeah.

976
01:23:40,028 --> 01:23:45,432
SPEAKER_01: Do you think in the future elections that identity politics will play a large role?

977
01:23:46,172 --> 01:23:51,917
SPEAKER_01: I'm curious actually, in fact, being a gay man yourself, did that play a role in your time running for president?

978
01:23:52,937 --> 01:23:53,918
SPEAKER_00: Everybody has an identity.

979
01:23:54,501 --> 01:23:57,944
SPEAKER_00: And your identity is part of your life and part of how society treats you.

980
01:23:58,084 --> 01:24:02,527
SPEAKER_00: And, and, and you may lean into it or you may not, but like, it's a thing it's there.

981
01:24:04,068 --> 01:24:13,735
SPEAKER_00: I think it's a mistake to imagine that that's the number one thing or the only thing that shapes how a voter decides who they want to be their leaders.

982
01:24:14,556 --> 01:24:18,379
SPEAKER_00: After all, for most of us, it doesn't dominate how you go about your everyday life.

983
01:24:18,919 --> 01:24:23,102
SPEAKER_00: Again, it matters, uh, in, in countless, huge overlapping ways for everybody.

984
01:24:24,525 --> 01:24:29,796
SPEAKER_00: But I think that one common mistake of the political kind of consultant class

985
01:24:30,700 --> 01:24:37,266
SPEAKER_00: is because those categories exist, you make that the number one way that you engage with voters.

986
01:24:37,306 --> 01:24:38,767
SPEAKER_00: You group them into these identity groups.

987
01:24:40,089 --> 01:24:46,314
SPEAKER_00: And so I'm gonna talk to black voters about black voter stuff, and I'm gonna talk to voters 18 to 24 about 18 to 24 year old stuff.

988
01:24:46,655 --> 01:24:48,356
SPEAKER_00: And I'm gonna talk to gay voters about gay stuff.

989
01:24:48,376 --> 01:24:55,823
SPEAKER_00: And like all of that might, you know, obviously every group has particular things that affect them as a group, but like,

990
01:24:56,924 --> 01:25:09,595
SPEAKER_00: if I'm talking about how to get a job or how to keep your job or how to make sure when you have a job that one job is enough to live on, that matters to every black voter, every gay voter, every 18 to 24 year old voter, every voter, right?

991
01:25:10,175 --> 01:25:21,905
SPEAKER_00: And so I think we recognize that identity plays a role in people's lives, but we lead with whatever's the most important thing in your life that's affecting whether your life goes well or poorly, at least which of those things government could make a difference on.

992
01:25:21,965 --> 01:25:22,726
SPEAKER_00: Where is government helping?

993
01:25:22,746 --> 01:25:23,546
SPEAKER_00: Where is government hurting?

994
01:25:23,747 --> 01:25:25,248
SPEAKER_01: And what would a better government,

995
01:25:25,768 --> 01:25:31,473
SPEAKER_01: Yeah, because those who are struggling financially, at the end of the day, that's what unites you.

996
01:25:32,093 --> 01:25:38,659
SPEAKER_01: In our country, at least the way that it exists today with lobbyists and businesses running everything, or at least seemingly everything.

997
01:25:38,719 --> 01:25:45,284
SPEAKER_01: So that's the uniting principle that can rally a base because the base doesn't have to be uniform.

998
01:25:45,324 --> 01:25:51,029
SPEAKER_01: In fact, we're so heterogeneous that we need to celebrate that and figure out how to make it work for us.

999
01:25:52,830 --> 01:25:54,331
SPEAKER_01: What does the next 10 years look like for Pete?

1000
01:25:55,092 --> 01:25:55,452
SPEAKER_00: I don't know.

1001
01:25:57,433 --> 01:26:01,156
SPEAKER_00: I'm not making any decisions this spring about running for office.

1002
01:26:01,236 --> 01:26:03,617
SPEAKER_00: Obviously, that's something I got to think about going forward.

1003
01:26:04,462 --> 01:26:12,127
SPEAKER_00: I know what I'm gonna do in terms of what my life is about, which is advancing values that I care about and believe in.

1004
01:26:12,967 --> 01:26:16,850
SPEAKER_00: Right now, I'm spending a lot of time supporting candidates and causes connected to those values.

1005
01:26:17,310 --> 01:26:22,354
SPEAKER_00: And that's things like going on podcasts or going on TV or traveling.

1006
01:26:22,394 --> 01:26:24,175
SPEAKER_00: We just did a big town hall in Tulsa.

1007
01:26:24,855 --> 01:26:27,097
SPEAKER_00: And I mentioned the one in Wisconsin.

1008
01:26:27,117 --> 01:26:28,037
SPEAKER_00: We do big events like that.

1009
01:26:28,057 --> 01:26:29,778
SPEAKER_00: We do smaller events, community round tables.

1010
01:26:30,179 --> 01:26:33,381
SPEAKER_01: I have an organization- Does it feel better doing it now without a specific-

1011
01:26:34,141 --> 01:26:34,541
SPEAKER_00: Agenda?

1012
01:26:34,862 --> 01:26:39,404
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean, I have an agenda in terms of, you know, wanting to make sure we surface important issues.

1013
01:26:39,424 --> 01:26:41,946
SPEAKER_00: But yeah, I'm not like there as the transportation secretary.

1014
01:26:41,966 --> 01:26:44,307
SPEAKER_00: And I'm not there, you know, asking people for their vote.

1015
01:26:44,427 --> 01:26:45,108
SPEAKER_00: At least not for me.

1016
01:26:45,128 --> 01:26:47,949
SPEAKER_00: I'm asking people for votes sometimes for candidates I believe in.

1017
01:26:48,250 --> 01:26:52,032
SPEAKER_00: We set up an organization called Win the Era, which kind of houses a lot of this work.

1018
01:26:53,032 --> 01:26:54,673
SPEAKER_00: I'm doing a lot of writing.

1019
01:26:54,693 --> 01:27:00,957
SPEAKER_00: I'm writing a book about what I think we could have if we weren't just constantly trapped in the status quo.

1020
01:27:01,117 --> 01:27:03,479
SPEAKER_00: Please don't put us in it negatively.

1021
01:27:03,559 --> 01:27:03,739
UNKNOWN: Yeah.

1022
01:27:05,260 --> 01:27:12,104
SPEAKER_00: I can guarantee you, unless something really strange happens in the next few minutes, I can guarantee you that much.

1023
01:27:12,685 --> 01:27:16,047
SPEAKER_00: So all through my life, I've realized that

1024
01:27:17,348 --> 01:27:20,971
SPEAKER_00: You can have more clarity about the difference you're trying to make than the job you're about to have.

1025
01:27:21,792 --> 01:27:26,575
SPEAKER_00: Never would have thought I was going to run for mayor until relatively soon before I actually did.

1026
01:27:27,877 --> 01:27:32,520
SPEAKER_00: Didn't think I would be running for president until a relatively short amount of time before I was.

1027
01:27:33,081 --> 01:27:40,907
SPEAKER_00: Made a lot of decisions to not run for certain offices because that wasn't the best way to make the difference I was hoping to make.

1028
01:27:41,550 --> 01:27:45,272
SPEAKER_00: And I guess the other thing I'd say is like, it's not just professional for me anymore, right?

1029
01:27:45,372 --> 01:27:59,300
SPEAKER_00: I mean, we've talked about my kids who like, you know, Chas and I are raising these incredible twins who just like every day are so hilarious and fun and also challenging.

1030
01:27:59,320 --> 01:28:03,762
SPEAKER_00: Like it's definitely the hardest thing we've done as well as the best.

1031
01:28:04,202 --> 01:28:08,666
SPEAKER_00: And so all of those things add up into life, right?

1032
01:28:08,846 --> 01:28:14,010
SPEAKER_00: The life you have at home and then the public life where you think you can make a difference.

1033
01:28:14,270 --> 01:28:16,432
SPEAKER_00: And I'm not trying to be cagey.

1034
01:28:16,452 --> 01:28:20,655
SPEAKER_00: I just literally have not made a decision about what to do next.

1035
01:28:20,715 --> 01:28:28,262
SPEAKER_00: But I'm sure whatever I do, whether it's running for office, whether it's writing more, whether it's more advocacy, will basically be about this.

1036
01:28:29,683 --> 01:28:31,664
SPEAKER_00: How do we live a better everyday life

1037
01:28:32,845 --> 01:28:38,291
SPEAKER_00: through ways of doing things in this country, especially our government, that are better than what we inherited.

1038
01:28:39,092 --> 01:28:48,502
SPEAKER_00: So that we know that our generation, just like generations before, will be better off than our parents and grandparents.

1039
01:28:48,963 --> 01:28:50,565
SPEAKER_00: That's no longer certain in this country.

1040
01:28:52,146 --> 01:28:52,626
SPEAKER_00: but it should be.

1041
01:28:53,407 --> 01:28:55,489
SPEAKER_00: And if we made different choices, it will be.

1042
01:28:56,049 --> 01:28:57,851
SPEAKER_00: And I'm going to work on that one way or another.

1043
01:28:58,431 --> 01:29:10,561
SPEAKER_01: So April, 2026, one to 10, what is your level of optimism that the world your children will grow up in will be a better world than today?

1044
01:29:12,503 --> 01:29:16,387
SPEAKER_00: I don't know that I can put that as a prediction, more as like, it's our assignment.

1045
01:29:16,427 --> 01:29:18,770
SPEAKER_00: Like, we've got to make sure that it is.

1046
01:29:19,570 --> 01:29:23,675
SPEAKER_00: I can't give it anything less than like, I'm going to make it a 10 with every fiver of my being, right?

1047
01:29:23,695 --> 01:29:24,495
SPEAKER_00: Because they're my kids.

1048
01:29:24,536 --> 01:29:26,918
SPEAKER_00: And like, they're going to ask, like when they're old enough to ask.

1049
01:29:26,958 --> 01:29:28,139
SPEAKER_00: I'm already getting a lot of questions.

1050
01:29:28,359 --> 01:29:31,242
SPEAKER_00: Right now there are questions I can handle.

1051
01:29:34,326 --> 01:29:35,307
SPEAKER_00: is Taylor Swift real?

1052
01:29:35,347 --> 01:29:38,410
SPEAKER_00: That's one I got when I was driving the kids to school the other day.

1053
01:29:39,330 --> 01:29:40,191
SPEAKER_00: It's like, yeah, she's real.

1054
01:29:40,792 --> 01:29:42,313
SPEAKER_01: Like they were worried she was an AI.

1055
01:29:42,333 --> 01:29:43,854
SPEAKER_01: She was that talented at singing.

1056
01:29:43,874 --> 01:29:46,396
SPEAKER_00: I think she's in the same category as Disney princesses to them.

1057
01:29:46,436 --> 01:29:47,077
SPEAKER_00: Ah, okay, fair.

1058
01:29:47,958 --> 01:29:53,262
SPEAKER_00: Which interestingly, they insist are also real because they saw Minnie Mouse at Disneyland once.

1059
01:29:53,282 --> 01:29:53,903
SPEAKER_00: Disney makes sense.

1060
01:29:54,163 --> 01:29:54,683
SPEAKER_00: So anyway.

1061
01:29:55,544 --> 01:29:56,124
SPEAKER_00: How do we get onto this?

1062
01:29:56,185 --> 01:29:56,545
SPEAKER_00: Where were we?

1063
01:29:56,725 --> 01:29:57,365
SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

1064
01:29:57,385 --> 01:29:57,625
SPEAKER_00: So, so, so.

1065
01:29:57,645 --> 01:29:58,746
SPEAKER_00: The future, the optimism level.

1066
01:29:58,786 --> 01:30:00,988
SPEAKER_00: So, like, now it's like, you know, it's Taylor Swift.

1067
01:30:01,108 --> 01:30:05,911
SPEAKER_01: So, your effort level for your optimism is a 10, but what is your actual optimistic level?

1068
01:30:06,051 --> 01:30:06,972
SPEAKER_01: I mean, we're at war.

1069
01:30:07,492 --> 01:30:08,393
SPEAKER_01: You were in the military.

1070
01:30:09,233 --> 01:30:09,393
SPEAKER_00: What?

1071
01:30:09,734 --> 01:30:10,174
SPEAKER_00: Oh, it's bad.

1072
01:30:10,474 --> 01:30:11,615
SPEAKER_00: It's bad.

1073
01:30:11,755 --> 01:30:15,557
SPEAKER_00: But my point is I'm going to put in the effort to justify an optimism level of 10.

1074
01:30:15,918 --> 01:30:16,198
SPEAKER_00: Got it.

1075
01:30:16,398 --> 01:30:18,740
SPEAKER_00: Because they're going to ask, like, what were you doing back in the 2020s?

1076
01:30:20,183 --> 01:30:23,626
SPEAKER_00: And I'm gonna have to say like, yeah, back in the 2020s, like it was crazy.

1077
01:30:23,646 --> 01:30:25,307
SPEAKER_00: People were going bankrupt because they didn't have healthcare.

1078
01:30:26,008 --> 01:30:27,869
SPEAKER_00: We were like, all this crazy stuff was going on.

1079
01:30:27,989 --> 01:30:32,513
SPEAKER_00: That sounds barbaric, you know, sitting here in the 2040s, looking back.

1080
01:30:32,933 --> 01:30:40,599
SPEAKER_00: But I want to be able to say I did everything I could to shape things, you know, with fellow citizens to make things better, which is why

1081
01:30:41,692 --> 01:30:55,271
SPEAKER_00: you two live in a world where you're confident that you're gonna be better off than our generation was and where nobody's losing their house or their shirt because of healthcare and where you have

1082
01:30:58,549 --> 01:31:13,001
SPEAKER_00: a shorter work week and more money in your pocket than before, because we took technologies like AI and saw to it that they didn't just lead to an explosion in inequality, but actually benefited people, which took hard work and tough calls and important policies.

1083
01:31:14,362 --> 01:31:23,570
SPEAKER_00: And the reason you feel like you live in a healthy democracy, as Americans often have, but sometimes haven't, like we didn't back in the 2020s, is we fixed it.

1084
01:31:24,010 --> 01:31:26,172
SPEAKER_00: So you get to fix the next round of problems that's coming along.

1085
01:31:26,232 --> 01:31:27,213
SPEAKER_00: We have to believe

1086
01:31:27,853 --> 01:31:28,673
SPEAKER_00: People did that for us.

1087
01:31:29,934 --> 01:31:32,835
SPEAKER_00: We've got to do it for them.

1088
01:31:33,175 --> 01:31:42,239
SPEAKER_00: I would not be optimistic at all if I thought we were confined to the status quo that we inherited, if I thought that things were just going to keep going the way that they're going.

1089
01:31:42,259 --> 01:31:45,600
SPEAKER_00: But the whole point of America is that they don't have to be.

1090
01:31:46,180 --> 01:31:51,582
SPEAKER_00: The whole point of America is if something's going wrong, it's because we let it, because we the people are in charge.

1091
01:31:52,042 --> 01:31:53,163
SPEAKER_00: Living, breathing document, right?

1092
01:31:54,544 --> 01:32:03,013
SPEAKER_01: It's kind of cliche, but dare I say, because it's a living, breathing document, we can be the life support that helps it continue breathing.

1093
01:32:04,254 --> 01:32:05,755
SPEAKER_00: Okay, yeah.

1094
01:32:06,116 --> 01:32:07,958
SPEAKER_01: I mean, hopefully more than life support, but yeah.

1095
01:32:08,338 --> 01:32:11,541
SPEAKER_01: I mean, I guess it depends on your level of pessimism in the current moment.

1096
01:32:11,641 --> 01:32:12,142
SPEAKER_01: I guess.

1097
01:32:12,182 --> 01:32:13,723
SPEAKER_00: No, we're doing better than that.

1098
01:32:14,704 --> 01:32:16,186
SPEAKER_00: Or at least we will be.

1099
01:32:17,349 --> 01:32:19,110
SPEAKER_00: But yeah, I'm not here to pretend things are better than they are.

1100
01:32:19,390 --> 01:32:34,701
SPEAKER_00: I'm here to say that precisely because we're in so much trouble as a country and precisely because so many things are being broken right now, we can come out of this building something that isn't just better than now, but it's better than before.

1101
01:32:35,541 --> 01:32:44,067
SPEAKER_00: If we do that, as ugly as the 2020s are in a lot of ways, especially politically, we could actually wind up being proud of this era if we use it the right way.

1102
01:32:45,271 --> 01:32:54,020
SPEAKER_01: I'll tell you this, you raised my optimism meter by at least a point, which is hard to do for someone who sees the dark depths of our healthcare system.

1103
01:32:54,040 --> 01:32:54,981
SPEAKER_01: So I thank you for that.

1104
01:32:55,442 --> 01:33:03,811
SPEAKER_01: And I thank you for this conversation, making the time to talk to a very engaged community who is passionate about making the world a better place, much like you are.

1105
01:33:04,251 --> 01:33:05,673
SPEAKER_01: So thank you for all your work in that regard.

1106
01:33:05,693 --> 01:33:06,654
SPEAKER_01: Likewise, thanks for what you do.

1107
01:33:06,674 --> 01:33:07,375
SPEAKER_01: Appreciate it.

1108
01:33:07,987 --> 01:33:13,431
SPEAKER_01: Speaking of the Department of Transportation, click here to see some of the most unhealthy things people do on airplanes.

1109
01:33:13,751 --> 01:33:15,472
SPEAKER_01: And as always, stay happy and healthy.